Volume 13, Number 1—January 2007
Tickborne Relapsing Fever Diagnosis Obscured by Malaria, Togo
Given the prevalence of relapsing fever (RF) in Senegal, this disease may cause illness and death in other areas of West Africa. We performed a cross-sectional, clinic-based study to investigate the presence of RF in Togo during 2002–2004. Blood samples from patients with fever were examined for RF spirochetes by microscopy, PCR, and DNA sequencing of amplicons and for antibodies to the glycerophosphodiester phosphodiesterase antigen. Although no spirochetes were seen in blood smears, ≈10% of the patients were positive by PCR and ≈13% were seropositive for spirochetes. DNA sequencing demonstrated that Borrelia crocidurae and B. duttonii were present. Most patients were treated for malaria whether or not plasmodia were observed. Thus, many RF patients originally had a misdiagnosis of malaria, which resulted in ineffective treatment. The inability of microscopic analysis to detect spirochetes compared with PCR demonstrates the need for tests with greater sensitivity.
Spirochetes of the genus Borrelia are known to cause 2 major types of human disease, Lyme disease, which occurs primarily in temperate regions, and relapsing fever (RF), which occurs in both temperate and tropical regions. Many vertebrates serve as enzootic hosts for the bacteria, and borreliosis is related to climatic and other environmental parameters required for the vectors and reservoir hosts (1,2). Borrelia-related disease is endemic in tropical and subtropical regions; B. hermsii and B. turicatae cause tickborne RF (TBRF) in North America. In Europe, TBRF is uncommon; B. hispanica is the causative agent in Spain, Portugal, Greece, and Cyprus (3,4).
TBRF in Africa is caused primarily by B. duttonii, which is transmitted by Ornithodoros moubata ticks in East and Central Africa, and by B. crocidurae, which is transmitted by O. sonrai in West Africa. Humans are the only known vertebrate host for B. duttonii. B. crocidurae is maintained in enzootic cycles in rodents and other small mammals. African TBRF is associated with proximity to tick-infested burrows and huts (4–6).
The primary clinical manifestations of RF are recurrent high fever interrupted by afebrile periods, hepatomegaly, splenomegaly, and anemia. These signs are similar to those of malaria. The fever peaks are associated with high spirochetemias, and antigenic variation leads to new antigenic variants of a major surface protein and the recurrence of high numbers of borreliae in the blood (7–10). When patients have high fever, spirochetes may achieve sufficiently high cell densities in the blood to be observed directly by microscopy when wet mounts of blood or Giemsa-stained blood smears are examined. Between peaks, the bacteria are too scarce to be visualized in the blood. Treatment with various antimicrobial drugs is effective (5,6); however, borreliae may rapidly invade the brain, and infection of the central nervous system may persist if not treated or if treated with antimicrobial drugs that do not readily penetrate the blood-brain barrier (5).
Research on RF in Africa has been limited, and little is known regarding the presence and geographic distribution of the spirochetes and tick vectors. Studies in Senegal indicate that RF is widely distributed and prevalent in this country; investigators speculate that RF may cause illness in rural areas throughout much of West Africa (11). A 2-year prospective investigation in a rural community in the Senegalese savanna showed that 10% of the study population became infected during the study period, resulting in an incidence of 5.1% (12). A recent 14-year longitudinal study demonstrated an average TBRF incidence of 11/100 person-years in Delmo, Senegal, and suggested that TBRF is a common cause of fever in most rural areas of Senegal as well as in some regions of Mauritania and Mali (13). In other areas of West Africa, where RF has not been identified, the disease is generally not considered in the diagnosis when patients have a fever.
We hypothesized that RF caused by B. crocidurae may be present in other areas of West Africa where the climate and environment are similar to that of Senegal. However, because of the lack of knowledge, diagnostics, and the high prevalence of malaria in these areas, RF remains undetected (14). Therefore, we conducted a study in Togo to determine if patients with fever might have RF. The study included examination of blood by direct microscopy, molecular methods, and serologic analysis.
Clinics participating in the study were located in the northern dry savannah and the southern tropical high plateau of Togo. The clinics were at the children’s hospital, Hopital d’Enfants, in Dapaong (urban/semiurban) in northern Togo and rural clinics in southern Togo, including the Centre Medico-Social de Sodo in Sodo, Hopital Bethesda, Agou Clinic in the Agou area, and the general hospital in Kpalimé, a town with ≈50,000 inhabitants (Figure).
Interviews and sampling were conducted from March 2002 through September 2004; sampling was performed from August through October in 2003 and 2004 in northern and southern Togo, respectively. Trained laboratory personnel in various clinics obtained blood samples, conducted interviews, and performed microscopic analyses. A total of 244 persons with fever were randomly selected; 14 persons without fever were included as controls.
A questionnaire that contained information on demography, living conditions such as building materials that may be favorable for nesting ticks and rodents, and occupation was used in interviews. Axillary temperature of each patient with fever was measured. Blood was collected from the arm by venipuncture or from a finger by lancet stick and applied to glass microscope slides. Thick and thin blood smears were stained with Giemsa and analyzed by microscopy at a magnification of 1,000× for plasmodia and at 400× for spirochetes. Microscopic examination for spirochetes was used at the clinics to enable diagnosis on site by the method routinely used in Senegal (14,15). Approximately 300 fields were examined to detect malaria parasites and borreliae. For malaria diagnosis, samples were examined for trophozoites and gametocytes. Blood and serum samples were stored at −20°C and shipped frozen to Sweden for further testing.
Plasmid Cloning and Protein Expression
Genomic DNA from B. crocidurae was used as a template for amplification of the glycerophosphodiester phosphodiesterase (glpQ) gene and subsequent sequence analysis (Table 1). The PCR amplification product was digested with BamHI and XhoI and cloned into the pET-15b vector (Novagen, Madison, WI, USA) as previously described (16). The resulting recombinant plasmid was transformed into the Rosetta strain of Escherichia coli. The heterologously produced histidine (His)–tagged GlpQ fusion protein was purified by using Ni-NTA spin columns (Qiagen, Valencia, CA, USA), and the protein concentration was determined with Bradford assay (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Hercules, CA, USA).
ELISA with Recombinant GlpQ Protein
An ELISA was used to detect anti-GlpQ immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies in patient sera and was performed as described by Porcella et al. (16). Briefly, His-GlpQ protein was adsorbed onto microtiter well surfaces of Ni-NTA HisSorb plates (Qiagen). Wells were blocked with diluent to inhibit nonspecific binding and washed. Serum samples were tested at a 1:100 dilution by incubating 100 μL/well for 1 h at room temperature. After 3 washes, 100 μL of a 1:2,500 dilution of goat anti-human IgG (heavy and light chains) conjugated to horseradish peroxidase (Kirkegaard and Perry Laboratories, Gaithersburg, MD, USA) was added to each well and incubated for 1 h. After 3 washes, 50% 2,2′-azino-di-(3-ethyl-benzthiazoline sulfonate) substrate was added and incubated for 25 min before analysis at 405 nm with a Multiskan microtiter plate reader (Labsystems, Vantaa, Finland). Each serum sample was tested in triplicate, and the mean absorbance value was determined. Samples were considered positive if their mean absorbance was greater than the mean plus 3 standard deviations of the absorbance of control sera tested at the same dilution. Serum samples from Ethiopian patients with RF were included as positive controls (16).
Blood Screening by Nested PCR
Blood samples that were positive or borderline positive by ELISA were tested by a nested PCR for Borrelia DNA. DNA was purified from the blood samples and 4 primers (Table 1) were used for detection of the 16S rRNA gene of borreliae. The first PCR amplified a 584-bp region of the gene with the primers Nested_1_F – Nested_1_R. The second PCR amplified a 498-bp region with the primers Nested_2_F – Nested_2_R. The amplicons obtained from the nested PCRs were sequenced to identify the Borrelia species because the primers were not able to amplify DNA from specific species of RF spirochetes.
PCR and Sequencing
For amplification of the complete coding sequence of glpQ gene from B. duttonii, 2 primers were designed by using B. hermsii noncoding sequences flanking the glpQ gene and 4 primers were designed by using sequences within the gene (Table 1). Nested PCR primers (Table 1) were designed to target the 16S rRNA gene. The PCR product for the B. duttonii glpQ gene was sequenced, and data were deposited in GenBank (accession no. DQ909058).
The study was approved by the Ethics Committee at Umeå University (Dnr 04–050 M). Informed consent was obtained at clinics from all patients or from the accompanying parent if the patient was a child.
Proportions were compared with a 2-tailed χ2-corrected (Yates) analysis and Fisher exact test. p values <0.05 were considered significant.
No patients were positive for borreliae by microscopic examination of Giemsa-stained blood smears. Among patients with fever, 9 (10%) of 90 children in northern Togo, and 5 (9.8%) of 51 children and 16 (16.3%) of 98 adults in southern Togo were seropositive by ELISA. A total of 12.6% of patients with fever were positive by ELISA (Table 2). For those patients without fever, 2 (14.3%) of 14 were seropositive. Because the glpQ gene is present in RF spirochetes but Lyme disease spirochetes are not, the positive serologic results strongly suggest that patients were infected with RF spirochetes (11). However, this serologic test is not species specific and cannot distinguish current from past infections.
Current Borrelia infections were detected by PCR and 16S rRNA gene sequence analysis in blood samples of patients from both northern and southern Togo. DNA sequencing identified both B. crocidurae and B. duttonii, but B. duttonii was found only in patients from northern Togo (Table 2). All 81 patients from northern Togo who were seronegative were also negative by PCR. In contrast, 8 (88.9%) of 9 patients who were positive by ELISA were also positive by PCR (p<0.05). All patients who were positive by PCR had a fever when their blood samples were collected.
A total of 28 patients from southern Togo were tested for current spirochetemias and included all ELISA-positive and some ELISA-negative patients. The negative samples chosen were those with the highest values below the cut-off value as well as randomly chosen samples with lower values. The 13 PCR-positive patients included 11 (55%) of 20 ELISA-positive patients and 2 (25%) of 8 ELISA-negative patients. Two samples from ELISA-positive patients could not be tested by PCR because the DNA was degraded. Both patient samples that were PCR positive and ELISA negative had ELISA values just below cut-off value used in the study.
All patients from northern Togo were children (age range <1–14 years). For children <4 years of age, 6 (10%) of 60 were seropositive. Of these children, 5 had a fever and 4 had an active Borrelia infection detected by PCR. DNA sequence analysis showed that 3 children were infected with B. crocidurae and 1 with B. duttonii. In southern Togo, 1 (9.1%) of 11 children <1–4 years of age were seropositive. The overall male-to-female ratio among study patients was 1.3:1. Serologic and PCR results did not differ by sex, ethnic background, or profession, with the exception of cow herders. The prevalence of seropositive adults was 62.5% (5/8) among cow herders compared with 12.2% (11/90) among those in other professions (p<0.05); 11 (78.6%) of 14 adults in the Peuhl ethnic group were cow herders (95% confidence interval [CI] 49.2%–95.3%), and 4 of 5 ELISA-positive Peuhl were cow herders. A total of 10.8% (95% CI 5.9%–17.8%) of all adults studied were cow herders. More Borrelia-infected patients lived in houses made of mud rather than cement than persons without RF infection (p = 0.008, data not shown).
The prevalence of malaria among patients with fever was 63.1%. Of 21 patients with PCR-confirmed Borrelia infections, malaria was diagnosed for 7 on the basis of a positive blood smear. Therefore, 7 (4.5%) of 154 patients were coinfected with malaria parasites and Borrelia (Table 3). In the youngest children (<4 years of age), 4 of 5 Borrelia-infected children also had malaria.
In northern Togo, patients infected with malaria and Borrelia were treated primarily with chloroquine, artemether, quinine, and amoxicillin. Borrelia-infected, malaria-negative patients were treated primarily with chloroquine, quinine, or amoxicillin. In southern Togo, patients with malaria and Borrelia infections were treated primarily with quinine and chloramphenicol for typhoid fever, metronidazole for amebiasis, and albendazole for digestive parasitosis. Borrelia-infected, malaria-negative patients were treated with chloroquine and antimicrobial drugs, such as amoxicillin, which are ineffective against RF Borrelia (Table 3) (14).
Although microscopic analysis of Giemsa-stained blood smears for Borrelia showed negative results, current infections were demonstrated by PCR and gene sequencing in 8.8% of patients with fever. Therefore, no RF infections would have been detected if only microscopic examination of stained blood smears had been performed. Our results emphasize the low sensitivity of microscopy in the diagnosis of RF, as has demonstrated by others (11,14,17). Another problem in diagnosis is that the borreliae are detectable only during the short peaks of fever (18). Microscopy might have shown positive results if dark-field or fluorescent microscopy had been used, but this was not possible in the clinics in this study. However, 1 of the primary objectives of this study was to improve the diagnosis of RF borreliosis by using molecular and serologic techniques.
A study of rodents in Senegal showed that 57.7% of Borrelia infections were false negative by microscopy (11). Microscopy is the method routinely used to diagnose B. crocidurae infections in Senegal, where the disease is common (14,15). Thus, methods that provide greater sensitivity are needed to determine more accurately the presence of RF throughout West Africa. Since the GlpQ antigen is present in RF Borrelia but absent in Lyme disease Borrelia, positive antibody test results strongly indicated that infections with RF Borrelia were occurring or had occurred (16). However, the infecting species and the time of infection could not be determined by this method. Positive serologic test results correlated with current infection, as demonstrated by PCR and sequence analysis. Thus, serologic tests may be more adequate for diagnosis, although ELISA procedures would have to be modified for use in small rural clinics.
Our finding of TBRF in Togo demonstrates that the geographic distribution of this disease in West Africa is greater than previously thought. Trape et al. suggested that RF caused by B. crocidurae might be spreading to new areas because of the sub-Saharan drought, which might allow vector ticks to colonize new areas in the savannas of West Africa (2). Our results suggest that this might be true. We also found RF caused by B. crocidurae in the tropical region of southern Togo, where the climate may be less favorable for its tick vector. Thus, habitats believed to be preferred by O. sonrai may need to be reconsidered. Southern Togo has been subjected to deforestation, periods of drought, and slash-and-burn agriculture. During the rainy season, the average temperatures in Dapaong and Atakpame are 24°C and 25.8°C, respectively, compared with dry season mean temperatures of 28.9°C and 26.8°C, respectively (19). The dry wind or harmattan from the Sahara Desert during winter can cause periodic droughts in northern Togo. We propose that areas with similar climate in West Africa are likely to have TBRF.
Of particular interest was our finding of B. duttonii in northern Togo, which extends the known distribution of this species in Africa. Additional work is needed to determine if its vector O. moubata is present in northern Togo or if B duttonii can be transmitted by O. sonrai. More studies are needed to determine the distribution of RF spirochetes and their vectors in Africa and what effect these infections have on human health.
Many of the primary symptoms of malaria and RF are similar, such as recurrent fever, chills, anemia, hepatomegaly, splenomegaly, and possible neurologic symptoms. Thus, a considerable risk for misdiagnosis of TBRF as malaria exists in countries in which RF is not recognized but in which malaria is prevalent. Occasional reports of European tourists returning home from Senegal with B. crocidurae infections have implied that the disease may be misdiagnosed as malaria, which leads to incorrect treatment (14,15,20). Because RF has not been investigated in most West African countries including Togo, the disease is generally not considered in a differential diagnosis for fever patients. Also, malaria is often diagnosed on the basis of only clinical symptoms, not examination for parasites in the blood, which increases misdiagnosis. Increased knowledge of the geographic distribution and epidemiology of RF in West Africa should improve the recognition and treatment of this disease. Prompt diagnosis of RF would also reduce the number of people in whom chronic symptoms such as neuroborreliosis later develop when bacteria cross the blood-brain barrier and infect the central nervous system (5,21,22).
We used a questionnaire to determine possible risk factors associated with RF. Some children <1–4 years of age were infected with RF Borrelia. Since O. sonrai is nocturnal, feeding mostly at night, these children may have been infected at home. However, RF among infants may also reflect infection from mothers before or during birth, as occurs with B. duttonii in East Africa (18). We also found that persons with current Borrelia infections more often lived in houses made of mud rather than cement. This observation is similar to ones in Senegal, where Ornithodoros ticks feed primarily at night inside mud or in adjacent areas where small mammals are present (2,6,20).
Before our study, we trapped 66 rodents and insectivores in or near houses in Togo. Four species were identified: musk shrew (Crocidura spp.), Nile rat (Arvicanthis niloticus), multimammate rat (Mastomys natalensis), and brown rat (Rattus norvegicus); 3 are known reservoirs for B. crocidurae in Senegal. These findings showed the presence of these potential reservoirs in northern and southern Togo (unpub. data). We found that mud huts were associated with entrances of rodent burrows, which might increase the risk for exposure to ticks (data not shown). In the present study, cow herders were also at a greater risk of acquiring RF. However, more studies are required to investigate potential risk groups. A higher proportion of cow herders who were ELISA positive were also Peuhl, who are nomadic people. Their behavior and sleeping outside at night may put them at greater risk of being bitten by nocturnal soft ticks.
We report TBRF in Togo with a prevalence of 8.8% among the patients studied. For those with fever, 63.1% had malaria and 4.5% were coinfected with RF Borrelia. Among those with RF, 33.3% were coinfected with malaria parasites. Given the retrospective finding of spirochetes by PCR, only 1 of 18 patients with TBRF received treatment effective against this disease at the time she was seen in the clinic. Thus, TBRF is obscured by the high incidence of malaria in Togo, and this problem likely occurs in other regions in West Africa. In rural health centers without laboratory facilities, diagnosis of malaria is based only on clinical symptoms. The potential risk for misdiagnosis and ineffective treatment of patients with RF rather than malaria needs to be addressed. Our findings demonstrate the need for improved diagnostic procedures to detect TBRF in West Africa. We consider the high prevalence of RF among febrile children and the lack of correct treatment as important health concerns, particularly with regard to the severity of untreated neuroborreliosis and women infected during pregnancy.
Dr Nordstrand is a medical microbiologist and epidemiologist at the Department of Public Health and Clinical Medicine/Epidemiology and Public Health Sciences at Umeå University. Her current research interests focus on relapsing fever Borrelia and other tickborne diseases in West Africa.
We thank Hospice Fonvi, Genevieve Carpentier, Egi Madeleine Goerki, Akutsa Kafui Amedzro, Kossi George Yakpa, the Association Protestante des Oeuvres Médico-Sociales et Humanitaires du Togo, Cecilia Norin, Peter Larsson, Anna Dahl, and Malin Ågren for their contributions to the project; Merry Schrumpf and Ingela Nilsson for their technical assistance; and Ingela Krantz for reviewing the manuscript.
The study was supported by a planning grant from the Swedish International Development Agency/Department for Research Co-operation, the Swedish Research Council (VR-M 07922), and the Swedish Foundation for International Cooperation in Research and Higher Education.
- Helmy N. Seasonal abundance of Ornithodoros (O.) savignyi and prevalence of infection with Borrelia spirochetes in Egypt.J Egypt Soc Parasitol. 2000;30:607–19.
- Trape JF, Godeluck B, Diatta G, Rogier C, Legros F, Albergel J, The spread of tick-borne borreliosis in West Africa and its relationship to sub-Saharan drought.Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1996;54:289–93.
- Anda P, Sanchez-Yebra W, del Mar Vitutia M, Perez Pastrana E, Rodriguez I, Miller NS, A new Borrelia species isolated from patients with relapsing fever in Spain.Lancet. 1996;348:162–5.
- Goubau PF, Munyangeyo C. Congenital relapsing fever caused by Borrelia duttoni. Apropos of a case in Rwanda.Ann Soc Belg Med Trop. 1983;63:367–9.
- Cadavid D, Barbour AG. Neuroborreliosis during relapsing fever: review of the clinical manifestations, pathology, and treatment of infections in humans and experimental animals.Clin Infect Dis. 1998;26:151–64.
- World Health Organization. Vector control: methods for use by individuals and communities. Geneva: The Organization; 1997.
- Barbour AG. Antigenic variation of a relapsing fever Borrelia species.Annu Rev Microbiol. 1990;44:155–71.
- Barbour AG. Borrelia species and antigenic variation.Trends Microbiol. 1993;1:236–9.
- Meier JT, Simon MI, Barbour AG. Antigenic variation is associated with DNA rearrangements in a relapsing fever Borrelia.Cell. 1985;41:403–9.
- Shamaei-Tousi A, Martin P, Bergh A, Burman N, Brännström T, Bergström S. Borrelia crocidurae induces formation of microemboli.J Infect Dis. 1999;180:1929–38.
- Trape JF, Duplantier JM, Bouganali H, Godeluck B, Legros F, Cornet JP, Tick-borne borreliosis in west Africa.Lancet. 1991;337:473–5.
- Lecompte Y, Trape JF. West African tick-borne relapsing fever.Ann Biol Clin (Paris). 2003;61:541–8.
- Vial L, Diatta G, Tall A, Ba el H, Bouganali H, Durand P, et al. Incidence of tick-borne relapsing fever in west Africa: longitudinal study.Lancet. 2006;368:37–43.
- van Dam AP, van Gool T, Wetsteyn JC, Dankert J. Tick-borne relapsing fever imported from West Africa: diagnosis by quantitative buffy coat analysis and in vitro culture of Borrelia crocidurae.J Clin Microbiol. 1999;37:2027–30.
- Brahim H, Perrier-Gros-Claude JD, Postic D, Baranton G, Jambou R. Identifying relapsing fever Borrelia, Senegal.Emerg Infect Dis. 2005;11:474–5.
- Porcella SF, Raffel SJ, Schrumpf ME, Schriefer ME, Dennis DT, Schwan TG. Serodiagnosis of louse-borne relapsing fever with glycerophosphodiester phosphodiesterase (GlpQ) from Borrelia recurrentis.J Clin Microbiol. 2000;38:3561–71.
- Kisinza WN, McCall PJ, Mitani H, Talbert A, Fukunaga M. A newly identified tick-borne Borrelia species and relapsing fever in Tanzania.Lancet. 2003;362:1283–4.
- Melkert PW, Stel HV. Neonatal Borrelia infections (relapsing fever): report of 5 cases and review of the literature.East Afr Med J. 1991;68:999–1005.
- Climate information for Togo. 2005. [cited 2006 Oct 17]. Available from www.climate-zone.com/climate/togo
- Colebunders R, De Serrano P, van Gompel A, Wynants H, Blot K, van den Enden E, Imported relapsing fever in European tourists.Scand J Infect Dis. 1993;25:533–6.
- Nordstrand A, Barbour AG, Bergstrom S. Borrelia pathogenesis research in the post-genomic and post-vaccine era.Curr Opin Microbiol. 2000;3:86–92.
- Nordstrand A, Shamaei-Tousi A, Ny A, Bergstrom S. Delayed invasion of the kidney and brain by Borrelia crocidurae in plasminogen-deficient mice.Infect Immun. 2001;69:5832–9.
- Figure. Locations of clinics in Togo involved in the study: 1, Dapaong; 2, Sodo; 3, Kpalimé; 4, Agou; 5, Bethesda; 6, sites of the community study in the Sodo region (adapted from......
- Table 1. Primers used for cloning, PCR, and DNA sequencing
- Table 2. Prevalence and identification of Borrelia infections in patients with fever at clinics in northern and southern Togo, 2002–2004
- Table 3. Coinfection with malaria and relapsing fever caused by Borrelia and treatment in patients in northern and southern Togo with fever, 2002–2004
Suggested citation for this article: Nordstrand A, Bunikis I, Larsson C, Tsogbe K, Schwan TG, Nilsson M, et al. Tickborne relapsing fever diagnosis obscured by malaria, Togo. Emerg Infect Dis [serial on the Internet]. 2007 Jan [date cited]. Available from http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/13/1/06-0670
Please use the form below to submit correspondence to the authors or contact them at the following address:
Sven Bergström, Department of Molecular Biology, Umeå University, SE 90187 Umeå, Sweden,
Comment submitted successfully, thank you for your feedback.
The conclusions, findings, and opinions expressed by authors contributing to this journal do not necessarily reflect the official position of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, the Public Health Service, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, or the authors' affiliated institutions. Use of trade names is for identification only and does not imply endorsement by any of the groups named above.
- Page created: June 28, 2010
- Page last updated: June 28, 2010
- Page last reviewed: June 28, 2010
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases (NCEZID)
Office of the Director (OD)