Volume 18, Number 9—September 2012
Yersinia enterocolitica Outbreak Associated with Ready-to-Eat Salad Mix, Norway, 2011
In 2011, an outbreak of illness caused by Yersinia enterocolitica O:9 in Norway was linked to ready-to-eat salad mix, an unusual vehicle for this pathogen. The outbreak illustrates the need to characterize isolates of this organism, and reinforces the need for international traceback mechanisms for fresh produce.
Yersiniosis, a notifiable disease in Norway, is the fourth most common cause of acute bacterial enteritis registered by the Norwegian Surveillance System for Communicable Diseases. Approximately 30 domestic cases are reported annually (2010 incidence rate 0.5 cases/100,000 population). In Norway, >98% of cases of Yersinia enterocolitica infection are caused by serotype O:3, which is also the dominant serotype in Europe, Japan, and parts of North America (1). Infection by Y. enterocolitica is often associated with ingestion of pork because pigs commonly harbor the pathogenic serotypes O:3 and O:9 (1). Recent foodborne outbreaks have been associated with pork products (2,3) and pasteurized milk (4).
In Norway, fecal specimens from patients who have acute gastroenteritis are routinely tested for the presence of Y. enterocolitica. Presumptive Y. enterocolitica O:3 and O:9 isolates are sent by primary laboratories to the National Reference Laboratory (NRL) at the Norwegian Institute of Public Health, where they are routinely verified, serotyped against a range of O antisera, biotyped if relevant, and tested for Yersinia virulence plasmid (pYV). If the strains are pathogenic Y. enterocolitica, they are typed by use of multiple-locus variable-number tandem repeat analysis (MLVA), using multicolor capillary electrophoresis (5). In March 2011, a multidisciplinary investigation was initiated after the NRL received 5 isolates of Y. enterocolitica O:9 from humans in disparate areas of the country. All had an identical MLVA profile, which had not been previously seen in Norway. An international request for information produced no reports of similar outbreaks.
A confirmed case-patient was defined as a person in Norway after January 1, 2011, who had laboratory-confirmed Y. enterocolitica O:9 infection that matched the MLVA profile of the outbreak strain. By May 5, the NRL had registered 21 outbreak case-patients (median age 37 years [range 10–63 years]), of whom 15 were female. Case-patients resided in 10 geographically dispersed municipalities throughout the country (Figure 1). Most case-patients became ill during February 7–March 20 (Figure 2).
We interviewed the first 7 case-patients by using a standard trawling questionnaire, which was subsequently shortened and used to test hypotheses in a matched case–control study. Two of the case-patients initially interviewed stated that they had eaten a specific blend and brand of salad mix. Nine case-patients were included in the case–control study. Three controls for each case-patient were selected from the National Population Register. Controls and case-patients were matched by age, sex, and municipality of residence and were interviewed in person or by telephone.
In the univariate analysis, ready-to-eat salad mix, diced ham, chicken breast, and arugula were statistically associated with illness (Table). Diced ham and chicken breast were rejected as likely sources of infection because the case-patients reported eating different brands purchased at different stores. Because arugula was an ingredient in the salad mix in question, it was not possible to otherwise distinguish it in the univariate analysis from the salad mix itself. The only food item that remained significant in the final multivariable model was salad mix. Sixteen of the identified case-patients reported having eaten salad mix.
We traced the suspected salad mix to a single Norwegian company. Under the auspices of the Norwegian Food Safety Authority, we conducted an environmental investigation, including a traceback investigation and a review of production and cleaning procedures at the company. The suspected salad mix contained 4 salad green types: arugula, radicchio rosso, iceberg lettuce, and endive. These ingredients came, unprocessed, from 12 suppliers in 2 European countries. After delivery to the company in Norway, the greens were washed in 2 cold water baths, cut, and packaged. We found no indications of inadequate routines for ingredient control, hygiene, or sampling within Norway. We identified radicchio rosso, a leaf chicory, as the likely source of infection because it can be stored for several months and was the only ingredient included in the suspected salad mix that had delivery, production, and storage dates consistent with the outbreak period. The company in Norway traced the radicchio rosso to 1 of 3 possible growers in 1 European country but was not able to identify the source of contamination. The Norwegian company voluntarily withdrew all salad mixes containing radicchio rosso from the market. After withdrawal of the implicated ingredients, no new outbreak cases were reported.
We collected 37 food samples from the homes of case-patients, retail locations, and the company that processed the salad mix products and analyzed them at the Norwegian Veterinary Institute. We cold-enriched all samples for 21 days and analyzed them according to conventional culture methods. Using PCR, we examined all enriched broths and isolated colonies for the ail gene, an indicator of pathogenic Y. enterocolitica that was found in the outbreak strain (6,7) (www.nmkl.org/kronologisk.htm). We cultured Y. enterocolitica–positive samples to isolate Yersinia colonies. We isolated presumptive Yersinia spp. from 11 of the salad ingredients, including 2 strains that were consistently positive for the ail gene and that were isolated from mixed salad and radicchio rosso samples obtained directly from the company. All of the specimens were sent to the NRL for characterization to the species level, biotyping, serotyping, and testing for pYV. The isolate found in the mixed salad sample was Y. enterocolitica biotype 1A. It did not agglutinate in antiserum 0 through 34 and was pYV negative, whereas the radicchio rosso isolate was identified as Y. kristensenii and agglutinated in O:11,24 antiserum.
This outbreak of Y. enterocolitica was associated with ingestion of ready-to-eat salad mix. Despite a thorough traceback investigation, the likely source of contamination for the outbreak, radicchio rosso, remains unproved. As found in many outbreaks linked to salad products (8–10), more women were affected than men or children. The outbreak was detected rapidly through systematic characterization of Y. enterocolitica isolated from humans to a level that enabled identification of an outbreak of non-O:3 Y. enterocolitica infections, which were linked by MLVA. Few European countries regularly type Y. enterocolitica, which might explain why international requests for information produced no similar reports from other countries.
To our knowledge, isolates of pathogenic Y. enterocolitica are seldom recovered from food samples. Previous survey studies of Yersinia spp. in prepared salads have recovered primarily nonpathogenic and environmental strains, such as Y. enterocolitica biotype 1A and Y. kristensenii (11,12). In addition, evidence is increasing that the ail gene is not always associated with pathogenic Y. enterocolitica, suggesting that ail-based detection methods for potentially pathogenic Y. enterocolitica in food should be supplemented by isolating the strain itself for further characterization or by investigating for other virulence markers. Strains of Y. enterocolitica biotype 1A, which are considered nonpathogenic, harbor the gene (13,14), whereas it might be absent from some pathogenic strains (15). Although we could not conclusively link any of the isolates from the salad ingredients to the human Y. enterocolitica isolates, finding nonpathogenic Yersinia in packaged salads reinforces that the environment of this food product is conducive to the persistence of the bacterium. No further outbreak cases were reported after the salad withdrawal, supporting our conclusion.
The necessity of epidemiologic, environmental, and traceback investigations in addition to microbiological investigation in outbreak situations cannot be underestimated. Considering the increasing number of outbreaks associated with fresh produce, improving traceback among these products should be emphasized. Despite the ultimately inconclusive traceback investigation, this outbreak shows the value of targeted surveillance and microbiological typing as a means for quickly identifying and investigating small foodborne disease outbreaks with international implications.
Ms MacDonald is an advisor in the Department of Infectious Disease Epidemiology at the Norwegian Institute of Public Health in Oslo, Norway. Her research interests include outbreak investigation and event-based surveillance.
We gratefully acknowledge the municipal health authorities and the employees of the microbiological laboratories at the community level in the affected areas who participated in the outbreak investigation; the personnel at the district, regional, and national levels of the Norwegian Food Safety Authority for conducting interviews with case-patients, collecting food samples, and collaborating on the international investigation; and the laboratory personnel of the Norwegian Veterinary Institute and Norwegian Institute of Public Health for performing the microbiological characterization and typing of human and food samples.
This work was funded by the Norwegian Institute of Public Health, the Norwegian Veterinary Institute, and the Norwegian Food Safety Authority, Oslo, Norway.
Part of this work was published as a Rapid Communication in Eurosurveillance (2011;16: 10–2).
- Norwegian Scientific Committee for Food Safety. A preliminary risk assessment of Yersinia enterocolitica in the food chain: some aspects related to human health in Norway. Oslo: the Committee; 2011.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Yersinia enterocolitica gastroenteritis among infants exposed to chitterlings—Chicago, Illinois, 2002. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2003;52:956–8.
- Grahek-Ogden D, Schimmer B, Cudjoe KS, Nygard K, Kapperud G. Outbreak of Yersinia enterocolitica serogroup O:9 infection and processed pork, Norway. Emerg Infect Dis. 2007;13:754–6.
- Ackers ML, Schoenfeld S, Markman J, Smith MG, Nicholson MA, DeWitt W, An outbreak of Yersinia enterocolitica O:8 infections associated with pasteurized milk. J Infect Dis. 2000;181:1834–7.
- Gierczyński R, Golubov A, Neubauer H, Pham JN, Rakin A. Development of multiple-locus variable-number tandem-repeat analysis for Yersinia enterocolitica subsp. palearctica and its application to bioserogroup 4/O3 subtyping. J Clin Microbiol. 2007;45:2508–15.
- Kirjavainen V, Jarva H, Biedzka-Sarek M, Blom AM, Skurnik M, Meri S. Yersinia enterocolitica serum resistance proteins YadA and Ail bind the complement regulator C4b-binding protein. PLoS Pathog. 2008;4:e1000140.
- Lambertz ST, Nilsson C, Hallanvuo S, Lindblad M. Real-time PCR method for detection of pathogenic Yersinia enterocolitica in food. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2008;74:6060–7.
- Nygård K, Lassen J, Vold L, Andersson Y, Fisher I, Lofdahl S, Outbreak of Salmonella Thompson infections linked to imported rucola lettuce. Foodborne Pathog Dis. 2008;5:165–73.
- Söderström A, Osterberg P, Lindqvist A, Jonsson B, Lindberg A, Blide US, A large Escherichia coli O157 outbreak in Sweden associated with locally produced lettuce. Foodborne Pathog Dis. 2008;5:339–49.
- Hilborn ED, Mermin JH, Mshar PA, Hadler JL, Voetsch A, Wojtkunski C, A multistate outbreak of Escherichia coli O157:H7 infections associated with consumption of mesclun lettuce. Arch Intern Med. 1999;159:1758–64.
- Brocklehurst TF, Zaman-Wong CM, Lund BM. A note on the microbiology of retail packs of prepared salad vegetables. J Appl Bacteriol. 1987;63:409–15.
- Szabo EA, Scurrah K, Burrows J. Survey for psychotrophic bacterial pathogens in minimally processed lettuce. Lett Appl Microbiol. 2000;30:456–60.
- Kraushaar B, Dieckmann R, Wittwer M, Knabner D, Konietzny A, Made D, Characterization of a Yersinia enterocolitica biotype 1A strain harbouring an ail gene. J Appl Microbiol. 2011;111:997–1005.
- Sihvonen LM, Hallanvuo S, Haukka K, Skurnik M, Siitonen A. The ail gene is present in some Yersinia enterocolitica biotype 1A strains. Foodborne Pathog Dis. 2011;8:455–7.
- Zheng H, Sun Y, Mao Z, Jiang B. Investigation of virulence genes in clinical isolates of Yersinia enterocolitica. FEMS Immunol Med Microbiol. 2008;53:368–74.
- Figure 1. . Geographic distribution of 21 outbreak cases (dots) of Yersinia enterocolitica O:9 infection, Norway, February–April 2011. Scale bar represents 100 kilometers.
- Figure 2. . Week of symptom onset or positive test result for 21 persons with Yersinia enterocolitica O:9 infection, Norway, 2011. Dark gray, date of symptom onset for 17 case-patients; light...
- Table. Results from univariate conditional logistic regression analyses of a Yersinia enterocolitica outbreak, Norway, February–April 2011
Suggested citation for this article: MacDonald E, Heier BT, Nygård K, Stalheim T, Cudjoe KS, Skjerdal T, et al. Yersinia enterocolitica outbreak associated with ready-to-eat salad mix, Norway, 2011. Emerg Infect Dis [serial on the Internet]. 2012 Sept [date cited]. http://dx.doi.org/10.3201/eid1809.120087
Please use the form below to submit correspondence to the authors or contact them at the following address:
Emily MacDonald, Department of Infectious Disease Epidemiology, Norwegian Institute of Public Health, Postboks 4404 Nydalen, NO-0403 Oslo, Norway
Comment submitted successfully, thank you for your feedback.
The conclusions, findings, and opinions expressed by authors contributing to this journal do not necessarily reflect the official position of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, the Public Health Service, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, or the authors' affiliated institutions. Use of trade names is for identification only and does not imply endorsement by any of the groups named above.
- Page created: August 17, 2012
- Page last updated: August 17, 2012
- Page last reviewed: August 17, 2012
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases (NCEZID)
Office of the Director (OD)