Volume 6, Number 6—December 2000
Nontoxigenic Corynebacterium diphtheriae: An Emerging Pathogen in England and Wales?
Confirmed isolates of nontoxigenic Corynebacterium diphtheriae in England and Wales increased substantially from 1986 to 1994. Ribotyping of 121 isolates confirmed in 1995 showed that 90 were of a single strain isolated exclusively from the throat; none had previously been identified in toxigenic strains from U.K. or non-U.K. residents. The upward trend in nontoxigenic C. diphtheriae probably represented increased ascertainment, although dissemination of a particular strain or clone may have been a factor.
Clusters of cases of sore throat associated with isolation of nontoxigenic Corynbacterium diphtheriae were detected in gay men attending a genitourinary medicine (GUM) clinic, military recruits, and children from a religious community in England and Wales in the late 1980s to mid-1990s (1-4). To determine the public health importance of the increase in cases, the Public Health Laboratory Service's (PHLS's) Streptococcus and Diphtheria Reference Unit and the PHLS Communicable Disease Surveillance Centre obtained more complete clinical information on nontoxigenic isolates referred in 1995 and 1996. Isolates received in 1995 were further characterized by molecular typing (ribotyping).
Laboratories in England and Wales routinely submit isolates of C. diphtheriae to the PHLS Streptococcus and Diphtheria Reference Unit for confirmation and toxin determination by both phenotypic (Elek and other immunoassays) and genotypic (polymerase chain reaction methods (5,6). Routine screening of throat swabs with selective culture media for C. diphtheriae was encouraged in public health laboratories in England and Wales (7). Clinical and epidemiologic information was obtained from questionnaires sent to referring laboratories and from laboratory request forms. Responsibility for completion and return of the enhanced surveillance questionnaire was taken by laboratory staff, in consultation with senior medical microbiologists and attending physicians with access to laboratory and medical records. The questionnaires, which included history of recent travel, symptoms and signs of illness, general medical history, clinical management (particularly antibiotic treatment, contact tracing, and treatment of contacts) and bacteriologic and virologic investigations, were sent retrospectively for isolates received by the PHLS diphtheria unit from January to June 1995 and prospectively through 1996 (8). Isolates confirmed as nontoxigenic C. diphtheriae during 1995 were ribotyped. The isolates were referred from laboratories in England, Wales, Scotland, the Channel Islands, and the Isle of Man. Analysis of ribotype patterns was done by using Taxotron (Institut Pasteur, France) software, as previously described (9).
In 1995 and 1996, PHLS confirmed 265 isolates from residents of England and Wales as nontoxigenic C. diphtheriae (Figure 1). The isolates were submitted by 80 laboratories located throughout each country; 28 (35%) were public health laboratories. Each laboratory submitted 1 to 27 isolates. Questionnaires were returned for 236 (89%) isolates. No pharyngeal membrane or systemic toxicity was reported. The age of patients whose isolates were tested was 1 to 87 (median 20) years.
Two hundred forty-seven (93%) isolates were from the throat, ten (4%) from skin lesions, one from blood, one from a nose swab, and one from bronchial washings; five were from unrecorded sites. Biotype var gravis accounted for 223 (84%), var mitis for 33(12%), and var belfanti for 9 (3%) isolates.
Of the 247 throat isolates, 238 were obtained as a result of clinical evaluation of patients with sore throats, and 9 were obtained from contacts of these patients. Of the 238 isolates obtained during evaluations, more than 25% were from male attendees at general outpatient or genitourinary medicine outpatient clinics (Table 1). Of isolates from females patients, 7% were from general outpatient clinics, and none were from genitourinary medicine outpatient clinics. Most isolates were from 15- to 24- year-old patients (Table 2). Of 238 throat isolates, 29 (12%) were from patients who had traveled outside the United Kingdom in the preceding 3 months, 20 to Western Europe, 4 to Australasia, 2 to Africa, 2 to the Indian subcontinent, and 1 to the Caribbean. Fever, lymphadenopathy, or both were reported in association with 72 (30%) of throat isolates. Nontoxigenic C. diphtheriae was reported as the predominant organism in 171 (72%) of the 238 throat swabs (Table 3) but was mixed with beta-hemolytic streptococci in 67 (28%). Penicillin was prescribed for 100 patients and a macrolide for 66, for a total of 166 (70%) patients treated according to current U.K. guidelines (10). Other antibiotics were prescribed for 7 patients and none for the rest. Viral throat cultures, reported for 10 (4%) of the 238 patients, were negative. Positive serologic results for infectious mononucleosis were reported in 10 (4%) patients. Seven isolates were associated with HIV infection, eight with psoriasis, one with gonorrhea, two with malaria, and one with cytomegalovirus infection and Crohn disease. Four of five laboratories referring 10 or more isolates reported that they had screened all throat swabs with selective media for C. diphtheriae during 1995 and 1996. These laboratories were located at two teaching hospitals in central London (25 and 19 isolates) and two public health laboratories, one in the Northwest of England (13 isolates) and the other in Wales (10 isolates). These 67 isolates were obtained from screening 32,345 throat swabs during the survey period. This rate corresponds to an overall rate of two isolates per thousand throat swabs (1.2 to 2.9 isolates per thousand throat swabs for each individual laboratory). Of the 10 skin isolates, 2 were var gravis, 7 var mitis, and 1 var belfanti. Nine were associated with travel outside the United Kingdom in the previous 3 months: to Africa (three patients), the Indian subcontinent (one patient), the Caribbean (two patients), and Southeast Asia (three patients). The positive blood culture was biotype var mitis, obtained from a 2-year-old with congenital heart disease whose illness was diagnosed as endocarditis 3 weeks after returning from Pakistan. The isolate from the nose was var belfanti mixed with Klebsiella aerogenes, taken from a 23-year-old man of Pakistani origin, who had a 3-month history of rhinitis but had not traveled in the preceding 3 months. The isolate from bronchial washings was var belfanti, associated with a malignant lung tumor in a 68-year-old man.
Taxotron analysis was undertaken in 121 (90%) of 135 specimens obtained for isolation from referrals from laboratories in all eight health regions in England and Wales during 1995; 115 of these had been obtained through clinical evaluation and 6 through contact tracing (Table 4). Travel outside the United Kingdom in the preceding 3 months was reported in association with isolates from 17 patients (Tables 4 and 5). Eight additional isolates that had been submitted by laboratories in Scotland, the Channel Islands, and the Isle of Man were ribotyped (Table 4). Twenty-three distinct patterns were detected and were designated A to W (Figure 2 and Table 4 and Table 5). Ribotypes A, B, C, and D were biotype gravis; ribotypes E, F, G, H, I, J, K, L, M, N, O, P, and Q were biotype mitis; and ribotypes R, S, T, U, V, and W were biotype belfanti.
Ribotype A was isolated only from the throat and accounted for 90 (74%) of 121 isolates from residents of England and Wales (Table 4). The isolates represented 78 of the 96 throat isolates from specimens obtained during clinical evaluation and not associated with recent travel, 7 of 11 throat isolates taken at investigation and associated with recent travel, and 5 of 6 throat isolates obtained at contact tracing (Table 4 and Table 5). Ribotype A also accounted for 4 of 8 throat isolates obtained at investigation from residents of Scotland, the Channel Islands, and Isle of Man (Table 4).
The remaining ribotype strains accounted for one to five isolates and were associated with a single health region or with travel outside the United Kingdom (Table 4 and Table 5). Ribotype E was isolated from the throat of one person who had recently traveled to the Gambia (Table 5). The five ribotypes from skin isolates were related to travel (Table 5); ribotypes H, M, and W were present in single isolates, while ribotypes D and J were also detected in nontravel-related throat isolates. Ribotype Q was isolated from blood of the 2-year-old with congenital heart disease and from the throat of a 4-year-old sibling. The nose isolate from the 23-year-old patient of Pakistani origin was ribotype V, and that obtained from bronchial washings of the 68-year-old man was ribotype S. All ribotypes from contacts were the same as their index case isolates. Ribotypes A, G, N, Q, P, L, and H formed a cluster with a genetic distance of <0.2, indicating greater than 80% genetic homology. Ribotypes L and H exhibited more than 90% genetic similarity.
One invasive infection with C. diphtheriae was associated with known risk factors. A single case of endocarditis without recognized risk factors was reported in England immediately before the survey (11). This picture is similar that of an Australian series in which three of seven cases of invasive infection had no predisposing risk factors (12). Most isolates were from throat swabs of young adults in primary care. The preponderance of female patients reflects the pattern of age- and sex-specific consultation rates for acute pharyngitis and tonsillitis (ICD 9th Revision codes 462 and 463) seen in general practice (13). Men attending genitourinary medicine clinics accounted for 5% of throat isolates, but there were no isolates in female patients from such settings. This is consistent with clustering previously noted in gay men but could be due to laboratory practice in hospitals serving large gay populations.
It is not known whether nontoxigenic C. diphtheriae were responsible for the illnesses that prompted the study. More than 25% of the 238 throat isolates obtained at investigation of sore throats were associated with beta-hemolytic streptococcal infection, infectious mononucleosis, or another illness; negative results for viral culture of the throat and for infectious mononucleosis were reported in a small proportion of the remainder. Community-based carriage studies and case-control studies, supported by comprehensive virologic investigation, will be required to obtain more complete information on the pathogenicity or copathogenicity of nontoxigenic C. diphtheriae in throat isolates.
Current U.K. guidelines state that when identified, nontoxigenic C. diphtheriae be regarded as a potential pathogen and be treated with penicillin or erythromycin if the patient has symptoms (10). Treatment was generally in accordance with these guidelines, but contact tracing, undertaken in 68 (26%) patients, and administration of a diphtheria immunization booster to 18 (8%) patients were not recommended. The few nontoxigenic C. diphtheriae isolates associated with chronic skin ulcers were mainly associated with recent travel to tropical zones.
A total of 23 distinct ribotypes were observed. However, ribotype A accounted for most isolates, was isolated exclusively from the throat, and was detected in isolates obtained throughout the United Kingdom. Seven of eleven throat isolates associated with a recent history of travel were also ribotype A, and it is possible that these were acquired in the U.K. Ribotype A predominated and appeared to circulate freely within the U.K. in 1995, which suggests that this strain may have some advantage in terms of transmissibility or pathogenic potential.
If nontoxigenic strains of C. diptheriae vary in factors associated with increased transmissibility of pathogenic potential, toxigenic strains may also vary in these factors. Toxigenic strains with these factors could be more likely than toxigenic strains without these factors to produce epidemics. This type of relationship may explain the appearance of an epidemic clone in the Russian diphtheria epidemic of the 1990s.
The marked variation in number of nontoxigenic C. diphtheriae isolates referred by laboratories in different regions probably reflected differences in the use of selective culture media for C. diphtheriae and practice in referral of isolates to PHLS. Increased professional awareness of the risk for imported diphtheria during the 1990s would have been expected to have increased both of these factors and may explain most, if not all, of the increase in the number of nontoxigenic C. diphtheriae isolates ascertained by the PHLS Streptococcus and Diphtheria Reference Unit during this period (Figure 1).
It has been suggested that nontoxigenic strains could become toxigenic by acquiring the tox gene, assuming that the chromosomal diphtheria toxin repressor gene (dtxR) is functional (14-16). However, no reports of membrane or systemic toxicity were received for any of our isolates, and ribotype patterns in the U.K. isolates for toxigenic and nontoxigenic strains differed. The rise in nontoxigenic strains from 1985 to 1996 and thereafter has not been accompanied by a rise in toxigenic isolates (Figure 1). These observations suggest that conversion to toxin production had not occurred despite continuing circulation of nontoxigenic strains. However, documented introductions of toxigenic C. diphtheriae into the U.K. are extremely rare.
Results from the four laboratories that routinely screen all throat isolates with selective culture media indicated a low isolation rate. This may not be seen as a cost-effective activity by many laboratories; less biased and cost-effective surveillance data could be obtained by undertaking selective culture for C. diphtheriae in population-based samples accompanied by strict compliance with reporting.
Our data confirm the known association of nontoxigenic strains with localized disease and with occasional cases of invasive infection, particularly endocarditis. There was no evidence that nontoxigenic C. diphtheriae would have posed an increasing threat to public health in England and Wales during the survey period.
Dr. Reacher is consultant medical epidemiologist at the Public Health Laboratory Service Communicable Disease Surveillance Centre in London. His current responsibilities are national surveillance for bacteremia and associated antibiotic resistance, gastrointestinal infections, and training.
We are grateful to colleagues in England and Wales for referring isolates, completing enhanced surveillance questionnaires, and providing information on laboratory workload; and to the staff of the PHLS Streptococcus and Diphtheria Reference Unit.
- Wilson AP, Efstratiou A, Weaver E, Allason-Jones E, Bingham J, Ridgway GL, Unusual non-toxigenic Corynebacterium diphtheriae in homosexual men. Lancet. 1992;339:998.
- Efstratiou A, George R, Begg NT. Non-toxigenic Corynebacterium diphtheriae var gravis in England. Lancet. 1993;341:1592–3.
- Wilson APR. The return of Corynebacterium diphtheriae: the rise of non toxigenic strains. J Hosp Infect 1995;30 Suppl 306-12.
- Efstratiou A, George RC. Microbiology and epidemiology of diphtheria. Reviews in Medical Microbiology. 1996;7:31–42.
- Efstratiou A, Maple PAC. Manual for the laboratory diagnosis of diphtheria. Copenhagen: World Health Organization; 1994:ICP/EPI 038 (C).
- Efstratiou A, George RC. Laboratory guidelines for the diagnosis of infections caused by Corynebacterium diphtheriae and C. ulcerans. Commun Dis Public Health. 1999;2:250–7.
- Public Health Laboratory Service. PHLS clinical microbiological standard operating procedure for the investigation of throat swabs London: Technical Services, Public Health Laboratory Service Headquarters; 1996. SOP 9 issue 2.
- Enhanced surveillance of non-toxigenic Corynebacterium diphtheriae infections. Commun Dis Rep CDR Wkly. 1996;6:29.
- De Zoysa A, Efstratiou A, George RC, Jahkola M, Vuopio-Varkila J, Deshevoi S, Molecular epidemiology of Corynebacterium diphtheriae from northwestern Russia and surrounding countries studied by using ribotyping and pulsed field gel electrophoresis. J Clin Microbiol. 1995;33:1080–3.
- Bonnet JM, Begg NT. Control of diphtheria: guidance for consultants in communicable disease control. Commun Dis Public Health. 1999;2:242–9.
- Booth LV, Ellis C, Wale MC, Vyas S, Lowes JA. An atypical case of Corynebacterium diphtheriae endocarditis and subsequent outbreak control measures. J Infect. 1995;31:63–5.
- Tiley SM, Kokiuba KR, Heron LG, Munro R. Infective endocarditis due to nontoxigenic Corynebacterium diphtheriae: report of seven cases and review. Clin Infect Dis. 1993;16:271–5.
- McCormick A, Fleming D, Charlton J. Morbidity statistics from General Practice: Fourth national survey 1991-1992. London: Office of Population, Census and Surveys. Her Majesty's Stationery Office; 1995: p. 250.
- Pappenheimer AM, Murphy JR. Studies on the molecular epidemiology of diphtheria. Lancet. 1983;2:923–6.
- Groman NB, Cianciotto N, Bjorn M, Rabin M. Detection and expression of DNA homologous to the tox gene in nontoxigenic isolates of Corynebacterium diphtheriae. Infect Immun. 1983;42:48–56.
- Cianciotto NP, Groman NB. Characterization of bacteriophages from tox-containing, non-toxigenic isolates of Corynebacterium diphtheriae. Microb Pathog. 1997;22:343–51.
Suggested citation: Reacher M, Ramsay M, White J, De Zoysa A, Efstratiou A, Mann G, et al. Nontoxigenic Corynebacterium diphtheriae: An Emerging Pathogen in England and Wales? Emerg Infect Dis [serial on the Internet]. 2000, Dec [date cited]. Available from http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/6/6/00-0614.htm