Volume 9, Number 1—January 2003
Risk for Pneumocystis carinii Transmission among Patients with Pneumonia: a Molecular Epidemiology Study
We report a molecular typing and epidemiologic analysis of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP) cases diagnosed in our geographic area from 1990 to 2000. Our analysis suggests that transmission from patients with active PCP to susceptible persons caused only a few, if any, PCP cases in our setting.
Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP) is an important cause of illness and death in immunocompromised patients, specifically HIV-infected patients, transplant recipients, and patients with oncohematologic diseases. In the absence of a reliable method of in vitro culture of the pathogen, many aspects of PCP epidemiology remain to be elucidated (1). Because of the evidence that contact with P. carinii occurs early in life, clinical infection in adults was thought to be mostly the result of reactivation of latent organisms. However, this concept has been challenged by evidence of the occurrence of de novo infection in HIV-infected persons (2,3). Possible sources include the environment, asymptomatic carriers, unrecognized infections, and patients with active PCP. Carriage by some persons with severe immunosuppression (4) or with chronic pulmonary disease (5) has been described recently. Direct transmission of P. carinii from patients with active PCP to susceptible persons is suggested by numerous reports of clusters of PCP cases, as well as by the demonstration of transmission of P. carinii in animal models (6). However, recent molecular typing failed to support this hypothesis in some studies (7–9). Indeed, different molecular P. carinii types were found in members of three different couples diagnosed with PCP (7), and the types were often different within clusters of PCP cases (8,9). Using molecular typing and epidemiologic analysis, we investigated the possibility of transmission of P. carinii between PCP patients who were seen in our region (about 500,000 inhabitants) during recent years. With few exceptions, all PCP patients are diagnosed at or referred to our hospital, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois.
From October 1990 to August 2000, 1,299 bronchoalveolar lavage specimens were examined at our hospital by using the Gomori staining method; 230 (18%) were positive for P. carinii (including eight recurrent episodes), among which 131 (57%) were available for typing (127 patients, four recurrent episodes). The typing system consisted of amplification by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) of four variable regions of the P. carinii genome, followed by the detection of the polymorphisms using the single-strand conformation polymorphism technique (SSCP). The four genomic regions are: the internal transcribed spacer number 1 of the nuclear rRNA genes operon, the intron of the nuclear 26S rRNA gene, the variable region of the mitochondrial 26S rRNA gene, and the region surrounding the intron number 6 of the beta-tubulin gene. These four genomic regions were shown to be stable over prolonged periods of time by using SSCP (10). The interpretation of SSCP results for typing has been described (11,12). A P. carinii type is defined by a combination of four alleles corresponding to the four genomic regions. This system has been validated (10–12). The SSCP typing system is easier and faster than DNA sequencing of multiple loci and allows the analysis of large collections of specimens. Moreover, this system detects a higher proportion of coinfections than typing by DNA sequencing of several genetic loci, probably because it is more sensitive at detecting alleles present in low amounts (11,13). This higher rate of detection is important for epidemiologic studies. The disadvantage of SSCP is that specimens containing more than two P. carinii types (about 30% of the specimens) cannot be typed because of the complexity of the alleles’ configuration (11).
The ages of the 127 patients ranged from 25 to 82 years (median 38), and 93 (73%) were men. Seventy-three percent (93/127) of the patients were HIV infected, and 27% were immunosuppressed from other conditions. Twenty-three (18%) of the 131 PCP episodes corresponded to an infection with a single P. carinii type, 66 (50%) to a coinfection with two types, and 42 (32%) to a coinfection with more than two types. The four patients with two PCP episodes were infected with different types at each episode. Altogether, 35 different PCR-SSCP types were observed (numbered as in a previous publication ).
To evaluate the proportion of PCP cases that could have resulted from transmission of P. carinii from a patient with active PCP to a susceptible person, we analyzed the distribution over time of the P. carinii types observed in the patients carrying one or two types (89 episodes, 39% of the cases in the period). Described clusters of PCPs (14–16) suggest that the incubation period of P. carinii infection may range from 3 to 12 weeks, which is also in accordance with experiments in animals (17,18). Accordingly, we hypothesized that the incubation period of a newly acquired infection would range from 3 weeks to 3 months and that a patient with PCP might be infectious from 1 month before diagnosis until the end of treatment (usually 3 weeks after diagnosis). A patient can be both a receptor of P. carinii and a donor. The Figure represents the receptor-donor period for each P. carinii type identified in a patient (a patient with a coinfection has two types). The distribution of the types over time was relatively homogeneous, suggesting the absence of outbreaks due to a single type. In only 19 instances did the periods of two or more isolates of a given type overlap.
To investigate whether these overlapping periods could reflect transmission of P. carinii between the members of the cluster, we calculated, for each type, the multinomial probability that the observed clusters occurred by chance alone using Monte-Carlo simulation experiments (we assumed uniform distribution over time). For types 1, 10, and 11, the probability was small (4.6%, 5.6%, and 5.4%, respectively). This probability is even smaller when we consider only 1990–1995 (before antiretroviral tritherapy was introduced), a period during which more cases were observed (1.5%, 2.3%, and 1.5%, respectively). This probability suggests that some clusters may indeed be the result of interhuman transmission of P. carinii (or of infection from a common source). However, 16 of the 19 clusters involved patients infected with different coinfecting types, implying that interhuman transmission was less likely (either the donor would have not transmitted both types or the receptor would have acquired one type elsewhere, or both).
We further investigated the possibility of transmission between members of each cluster using available epidemiologic data limited to the location of patients’ residence and documented time in the hospital. None of the patients involved in the 19 clusters lived in the same city sector or the same town. To investigate the possibility of encounters in the hospital, timing and location of consultations and hospitalizations were determined by review of the patients’ medical charts and the outpatient clinic’s schedule. An encounter was considered compatible with an interhuman transmission of P. carinii if an “infectious” and a “susceptible” patient (as defined above) were present in the same ward or facility of the hospital on the same day. Analyses of all identified clusters did not reveal any hospital encounters. Because the period at risk of acquisition and transmission chosen might have been too restrictive, we also analyzed four clusters of patients with identical typing results but with PCP episodes occurring up to 10 months apart. Again, no encounter in the hospital, as defined above, was found.
Because the analyzed specimens represent only 39% (89/230) of the PCP episodes of the period, the possibility of a selection bias can be raised. Such bias cannot be firmly excluded but statistical analysis argues against it, at least for the period before antiretroviral tritherapy was introduced (a period covering 51% [87/171] of the specimens available). Statistical analysis showed that the distribution over time of the available specimens was not significantly different from that of the cases that were unavailable (Wilcoxon rank sum test; p=0.55), suggesting that the results for this period are representative of the overall situation. On the other hand, the two distributions for the period from 1996 to 2000 were different because the proportion of specimens stored for typing increased regularly during the period (p=0.07; 75% [44/59] of the specimens available).
Our study reports on a large number of PCP episodes observed for >10 years. Although our retrospective analysis does not allow us to exclude encounters of the clustered cases outside the hospital, the results strongly suggest that transmission of P. carinii by a patient with active PCP to a susceptible person contributed to only a very small number, if any, of the PCP cases in our geographic area during this period. The broad diversity of observed types suggests that the patients acquired P. carinii from multiple unknown sources not addressed in the present study. Moreover, hospital epidemiologic data and molecular typing did not provide evidence of transmission of P. carinii inside the hospital between members of clusters infected with the same P. carinii type. Thus, the main source of P. carinii is unlikely to be represented by patients with active PCP.
E. Senggen Manoloff has completed her medical degree at the University of Lausanne. The present work, which she performed under the supervision of P. Hauser and P. Francioli, constitutes her thesis to comply with the Swiss requirements for postgraduate specialization.
We thank A. Cruchon for excellent technical assistance.
This work was supported by grant 97-7299 of the Swiss National Program on AIDS Research.
- Morris A, Beard BC, Huang L. Update on the epidemiology and transmission of Pneumocystis carinii. Microbes Infect. 2002;4:95–103.
- Keely SP, Stringer JR, Baughman RP, Linke MJ, Walzer PD, Smulian AG. Genetic variation among Pneumocystis carinii hominis isolates in recurrent pneumocystosis. J Infect Dis. 1995;172:595–8.
- Keely SP, Baughman RP, Smulian AG, Dohn MN, Stringer JR. Source of Pneumocystis carinii in recurrent episodes of pneumonia in AIDS patients. AIDS. 1996;10:881–8.
- Hauser PM, Blanc DS, Bille J, Nahimana A, Francioli P. Carriage of Pneumocystis carinii by immunosuppressed patients and molecular typing of the organisms. AIDS. 2000;14:461–3.
- Calderon EJ, Regordan C, Medrano FJ, Ollero M, Varela JM. Pneumocystis carinii infection in patients with chronic bronchial disease. Lancet. 1996;347:977.
- Hughes WT. Natural mode of acquisition for de novo infection with Pneumocystis carinii. J Infect Dis. 1982;145:842–8.
- Latouche S, Poirot JL, Maury E, Bertrand V, Roux P. Pneumocystis carinii hominis sequencing to study hypothetical person-to-person transmission. AIDS. 1997;11:549.
- Helweg-Larsen J, Tsolaki AG, Miller RF, Lundgren B, Wakefield AE. Clusters of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia: analysis of person-to-person transmission by genotyping. QJM. 1998;91:813–20.
- Olsson M, Eriksson BM, Elvin K, Strandberg M, Wahlgren M. Genotypes of clustered cases of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia. Scand J Infect Dis. 2001;33:285–9.
- Hauser PM, Blanc DS, Sudre P, Senggen Manoloff E, Nahimana A, Bille J, Genetic diversity of Pneumocystis carinii in HIV-positive and -negative patients as revealed by PCR-SSCP typing. AIDS. 2001;15:461–6.
- Nahimana A, Blanc DS, Francioli P, Bille J, Hauser PM. Typing of Pneumocystis carinii f.sp. hominis by PCR-SSCP to indicate high frequency of co-infections. J Med Microbiol. 2000;49:753–8.
- Hauser PM, Francioli P, Bille J, Telenti A, Blanc DS. Typing of Pneumocystis carinii f. sp. hominis by single-strand conformation polymorphism of four genomic regions. J Clin Microbiol. 1997;35:3086–91.
- Hauser PM, Blanc DS, Bille J, Francioli P. Typing methods to approach Pneumocystis carinii genetic heterogeneity. FEMS Immunol Med Microbiol. 1998;22:27–35.
- Chave JP, David S, Wauters JP, Van Melle G, Francioli P. Transmission of Pneumocystis carinii from AIDS patients to other immunosuppressed patients: a cluster of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia in renal transplant recipients. AIDS. 1991;5:927–32.
- Goesch TR, Gotz G, Stellbrinck KH, Albrecht H, Weh HJ, Hossfeld DK. Possible transfer of Pneumocystis carinii between immunodeficient patients. Lancet. 1990;336:627.
- Singer C, Armstrong D, Rosen PP, Schottenfeld D. Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia: a cluster of eleven cases. Ann Intern Med. 1975;82:772–7.
- Boylan CJ, Current WL. Improved rat model of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia: induced laboratory infections in Pneumocystis-free animals. Infect Immun. 1992;60:1589–97.
- Powles MA, McFadden DC, Pittarelli LA, Schmatz DM. Mouse model for Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia that uses natural transmission to initiate infection. Infect Immun. 1992;60:1397–400.
Comments to the Authors
West Nile Virus RNA
in Tissues from Donor
Transmission to Organ