Chapter 8Advising Travelers With Specific Needs
Humanitarian Aid Workers
Through organizations and agencies or individual activities, many thousands of people are involved in the delivery of humanitarian aid in diverse locations every year. After large-scale events such as earthquakes or tsunamis, the number of those traveling to provide humanitarian aid and assistance can increase. Maintaining the health of humanitarian aid workers is important to ensure that they are able to deliver care to those in need and avoid additional strain on local health services.
In common with other travelers, people who travel to provide humanitarian aid or disaster relief must first address their personal health and welfare before, during, and after travel. This includes knowledge of and preparation for all the usual elements associated with travel to the area. In addition, aid workers can experience specific risks and situations related to the provision of humanitarian care, such as:
- Exposure to the environment that precipitated or sustains a crisis or event, such as a natural disaster or conflict
- Working long hours under adverse or extreme conditions, often in close contact with the affected population
- Damaged or absent infrastructure, including limits in the availability of food, water, lodging, transportation, and health services
- Reduced levels of security and protection
- Stress, ethical, and moral challenges related to the event and the resource capacities of the situation
Humanitarian service can damage personal health. Studies involving long-term humanitarian workers have noted that >35% report that their personal health status deteriorated during the mission. Accidents and violence are documented risks for humanitarian aid workers and cause more deaths than disease and natural causes. Recent estimates place the risk of violence-related deaths, medical evacuations, and hospitalizations at approximately 6 per 10,000 person-years among aid workers. Conditions and outcomes vary by location, nature of the humanitarian event, and time spent in the field.
A recent study of American Red Cross workers noted a 10% ratio of injury or accident and an exposure to violence of 16%. That study also showed that >40% found the experience more stressful than expected. An earlier study of deaths among Peace Corps volunteers noted that unintentional injuries were the cause of nearly 70% of deaths, followed by homicide at 17%. Illness was responsible for 14% of the Peace Corps fatalities.
However, risks to humanitarian aid workers are not uniformly distributed across the spectrum of humanitarian aid. For example, in 2009 a survey of violence against humanitarian aid workers found that a small number of insecure locations (Afghanistan, Darfur [Sudan], and Somalia) accounted for >60% of these events.
Evaluation and Pre-Travel Medical Care
Giving careful attention to pre-travel evaluation, both medical and psychological, in addition to educating travelers can reduce the likelihood of illness and the need for repatriation. Comprehensive medical examinations can prepare travelers by helping identify previously unrecognized disease and allowing for treatment before travel. Careful evaluation of risk factors (family history, history of alcohol or substance abuse, sexually transmitted diseases, and psychiatric illness) may direct additional evaluation and identify previously unrecognized psychological problems or chronic conditions. Identifying alcohol or substance dependence, depression, or other psychiatric illness is important, as these conditions may be exacerbated by the stress of the mission and are often the reason for emergency repatriation. People planning long-term assignments should have their dental condition assessed and any problems dealt with before departure.
Those who will be providing medical care or participating in clinical research as part of their humanitarian activities should be evaluated in terms of occupational risk and the need for preventive preexposure or postexposure interventions. Humanitarian aid workers destined for areas of active conflict or limited police presence may benefit from specialized security briefings, either provided by the employing agency or private sources. Medical facilities may be compromised by the disaster or overwhelmed in responding to it. Therefore, volunteers with underlying conditions or pregnant women should be counseled against travel and encouraged to support the response in other ways.
Regardless of the area of the world in which the aid worker will be deployed, certain basics should be addressed in the pre-travel encounter, including routine vaccinations, malaria chemoprophylaxis (if appropriate), food and water precautions, self-treatment for travelers’ diarrhea, risks from insect bites, and injury prevention.
Counseling and Advice
Predeployment education and training are essential, as personal illness or injury burdens the community the worker has come to support. Injuries and motor vehicle accidents are common risks for travelers anywhere in the world; thus, travelers should be sensitive to their surroundings and carefully select the type of transportation and hour of travel, if possible. In disaster and emergency situations, the traveler should also be aware of physical hazards such as debris, unstable structures, downed power lines, environmental hazards, and extremes of temperature. Although rare, emergency situations in developed nations may involve unusual exposures, such as radiation exposures observed after damage to nuclear facilities in Japan in 2011.
Travelers to conflict areas should be aware of landmines and other potential hazards associated with unexploded ordnance. In situations associated with damage or destruction to local services and facilities, humanitarian aid workers should expect, anticipate, and plan for limited accommodations, logistics, and personal support. Humanitarian aid workers destined for low-resource areas or situations may benefit from pre-travel training and counseling regarding the moral complexities of providing service in these environments.
The traveler should be advised to prepare a travel health kit that is more extensive than the typical kit and should also be familiar with basic first aid to self-treat any injury until medical attention can be obtained. Aid workers may need to disinfect their own water and may want to carry high-energy, nonperishable food items for emergency use. Humanitarian aid workers should research the available resources in the destination to tailor how extensive their packed supplies should be. People with dental crowns or bridgework may wish to carry temporary dental adhesive for short-term management of a dislodged dental appliance. In addition to a basic travel health kit (see Chapter 2, Travel Health Kits), humanitarian aid workers should consider bringing the following items:
- Toothbrush and toothpaste
- Skin moisturizer
- Soap, shampoo
- Lip balm
- If corrective lenses are used:
- Extra pair of prescription glasses in a protective case and a copy of the prescription
- Eyeglasses cleaning supplies and repair kit
- Extra contact lenses and lens cleaner
- Razor, extra blades1
- Nail clippers1
- Toilet paper
- Menstrual supplies
- Sewing kit
- Laundry detergent
- Small clothesline and clothespins
- Comfortable, lightweight clothing
- Long pants
- Long-sleeved shirts
- Shower shoes
- Rain gear
- Bandana or handkerchief
- Towel (highly absorbent travel towel if possible)
- Gloves (leather gloves if physical labor will be performed; rubber gloves if handling blood or body fluids)
Items for daily living
- Waterproof watch
- Spare batteries
- Travel plug adapters for electronics
- Knife, such as a Swiss Army knife or Leatherman1
- If traveling to an area where food and water may be contaminated:
- Bottled water or water filters/purification system/water purification tablets
- Nonperishable food items
- If traveling to malaria-endemic areas:
- Personal bed net (insecticide-impregnated)
Safety and security
- Money belt
- Cellular telephone, equipped to work internationally, or satellite telephone (with charger)
- Candles, matches, and lighter in a zip-top bag2
- Extra zip-top bags
- Safety goggles
1Pack these items in checked baggage, since they are considered sharp objects and will be confiscated by airport or airline security if packed in carry-on bags.
2See www.tsa.gov for restrictions on traveling with lighters and matches.
Because of the loss of life, serious injuries, missing and separated families, and destruction often associated with disasters, humanitarian aid workers should recognize that situations they encounter may be extremely stressful. Keeping a personal item nearby, such as a family photo, favorite music, or religious material, can offer comfort in such situations. Checking in with family members and close friends from time to time is another means of support. Satellite telephones are small, can work almost anywhere in the world, and can be rented for <$10 per day.
In uncertain circumstances, extra passport-style photos may be required for certain types of visas or for additional work permits. Travelers should bring photocopies of important documents, such as passports and credit cards, as well as copies of their medical or nursing license, if applicable. Medical information, such as immunization records and blood type, is also helpful to have. The traveler should carry these copies and also leave a copy with someone back home. In addition, they should carry contact information for the person who should be notified in an emergency.
Registration with Embassies
Travelers should register with the US embassy in the destination country before departure, so that the local consulate is aware of their presence, and they may be accounted for and included in evacuation plans. They should also consider supplemental travel, travel health, and medical evacuation insurance to cover medical care and evacuation should they become ill or injured. See the Department of State website for additional information (https://travelregistration.state.gov/ibrs/ui).
Returning humanitarian aid workers should be advised to seek medical care if they sustained injuries during their travel or become ill after returning. To ensure proper evaluation, they should advise their providers of the nature of their recent travel.
Depending upon the length of time away or their activities (such as working in health care), returning aid workers may benefit from a complete medical review. Homecoming has also been identified as a risk period for difficulties in psychological adjustment, and treatment or counseling should be sought. Workers who witnessed or were involved in situations of mass casualties, deaths, or serious injuries or who have been victims of violence (assault, kidnapping, or serious road traffic crash) should be considered for referral for critical incident counseling.
Studies have indicated that >30% of aid workers report depression shortly after returning home. The adjustment process can be assisted by a skilled debriefing. Generally, humanitarian aid workers are able to adapt to the acute and chronic stressors of their work and demonstrate considerable resilience, but they will also benefit from proper rest and support to help them fully adjust back into the home environment.
- Callahan MV, Hamer DH. On the medical edge: preparation of expatriates, refugee and disaster relief workers, and Peace Corps volunteers. Infect Dis Clin North Am. 2005 Mar;19(1):85–101.
- Campbell S. Responding to international disasters. Nurs Stand. 2005 Feb 2–8;19(21):33–6.
- CDC. Coping with a traumatic event: information for the public. Atlanta: CDC; 2009 [cited 2012 Sep 23]. Available from: http://www.bt.cdc.gov/masscasualties/copingpub.asp.
- Connorton E, Perry MJ, Hemenway D, Miller M. Humanitarian relief workers and trauma-related mental illness. Epidemiol Rev. 2012 Jan;34(1):145–55.
- Coppola DP. Introduction to International Disaster Management. Amsterdam: Butterworth Heinemann; 2006.
- Egeland J, Harmer A, Stoddard A. To stay and deliver: good practice for humanitarians in complex security environments. New York: United Nations; 2011 [cited 2012 Sep 23]. Available from: http://ochanet.unocha.org/p/Documents/Stay_and_Deliver.pdf.
- Gamble K, Lovell D, Lankester T, Keystone JS. Aid workers, expatriates and travel. In: Zuckerman J, editor. Principles and Practice of Travel Medicine. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley; 2001. p. 448–66.
- Jung P, Banks RH. Tuberculosis risk in US Peace Corps Volunteers, 1996 to 2005. J Travel Med. 2008 Mar–Apr;15(2):87–94.
- Kortepeter MG, Seaworth BJ, Tasker SA, Burgess TH, Coldren RL, Aronson NE. Health care workers and researchers traveling to developing-world clinical settings: disease transmission risk and mitigation. Clin Infect Dis. 2010 Dec 1;51(11):1298–305.
- Leaning J, Spiegel P, Crisp J. Public health equity in refugee situations. Confl Health. 2011;5:6.
- McFarlane CA. Risk associated with the psychological adjustment of humanitarian aid workers. The Australas J Disaster Trauma Stud [serial on the Internet]. 2004 [cited 2012 Sep 23]. Available from: http://www.massey.ac.nz/~trauma/issues/2004-1/mcfarlane.htm.
- Mitchell AM, Sakraida TJ, Kameg K. Critical incident stress debriefing: implications for best practice. Disaster Manag Response. 2003 Apr–Jun;1(2):46–51.
- Nurthen NM, Jung P. Fatalities in the Peace Corps: a retrospective study, 1984 to 2003. J Travel Med. 2008 Mar–Apr;15(2):95–101.
- Pearn J. Pre-deployment education and training for refugee emergencies: health and safety aspects. J Refug Stud. 1997;10:495–502.
- Peytremann I, Baduraux M, O’Donovan S, Loutan L. Medical evacuations and fatalities of United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees field employees. J Travel Med. 2001 May–Jun;8(3):117–21.
- Sheik M, Gutierrez MI, Bolton P, Spiegel P, Thieren M, Burnham G. Deaths among humanitarian workers. BMJ. 2000 Jul 15;321(7254):166–8.
- Stoddard A, Harmer A, Renouf JS. Once removed: lessons and challenges in remote management of humanitarian operations for insecure areas. New York: Humanitarian Outcomes; 2010 [cited 2012 Sep 23]. Available from: www.humanitarianoutcomes.org/resources/RemoteManagementApr20101.pdf.