Volume 18, Number 8—August 2012
Chloroquine-Resistant Malaria in Travelers Returning from Haiti after 2010 Earthquake
We investigated chloroquine sensitivity to Plasmodium falciparum in travelers returning to France and Canada from Haiti during a 23-year period. Two of 19 isolates obtained after the 2010 earthquake showed mixed pfcrt 76K+T genotype and high 50% inhibitory concentration. Physicians treating malaria acquired in Haiti should be aware of possible chloroquine resistance.
In Haiti (2011 population ≈9.7 million), malaria is endemic. Approximately 30,000 malaria infections are confirmed annually among ≈200,000 estimated malaria cases, mainly Plasmodium falciparum infections (1). On January 12, 2010, a 7.0 magnitude earthquake struck Haiti near Port-au-Prince, leaving much of the population homeless.
The main malaria vector in Haiti, Anopheles albimanus mosquitoes, which mostly bite outdoors during November–January, placed evacuees at high risk for infection (2,3). Severe flooding after hurricane Tomas in November 2010 probably compounded the problem by facilitating parasite reservoirs and mosquito breeding (4). Some studies suggest that these events might have increased malaria transmission in Haiti. Two observational surveys, 1 performed by a mobile medical team during March–April 2010 (5) and 1 during November 2010–February 2011 in a primary care clinic in Leogane (6), reported a high proportion of malaria infection among persons with fever (20.3% and 46.9%, respectively) compared with reports from a population-based survey in 2006 (14.2%) (2). The US National Malaria Surveillance System reported a 3-fold increase in malaria among travelers returning from Haiti in 2010 (170 cases) compared with 2009 (58 cases) (7).
Chloroquine associated with primaquine since 2009, is the recommended first-line treatment for uncomplicated malaria. In vitro and molecular surveillance data collected during the past 2 decades suggest continued P. falciparum sensitivity to chloroquine (3,8,9). However, a 2006–2007 study in Artibonite Valley, Haiti, showed the chloroquine resistance–associated Pfcrt76T genotype in ≈6% (5/79) of P. falciparum isolates, although clinical data were lacking (10). Subsequently, the Haitian Ministry of Health acknowledged that routine chloroquine efficacy surveillance should be reinforced (11). We investigated the chloroquine sensitivity of P. falciparum parasites isolated from travelers recently returned from Haiti to Canada and France by using genotypic and phenotypic methods.
We collected retrospective data from the National Malaria Reference Centre (Paris, France) and Public Health Ontario (Toronto, ON, Canada) during 1988–2010 and 2007–2010, respectively. P. falciparum infection was considered probably acquired in Haiti if biologically confirmed by thin and thick blood smears from persons who had recently traveled to Haiti in the 2 months before infection was diagnosed. Basic demographic and epidemiologic data, clinical and parasitologic information, treatment, and history of travel and P. falciparum infection were collected systematically. Forty of 80 participating hospitals in the sentinel network in France also documented resistance to antimalarial drugs. Pretreatment isolates were collected to determine chloroquine susceptibility by molecular analysis of the Pfcrt76 locus and by comparing the ratio of in vitro chloroquine response of the clinical isolate with a chloroquine-sensitive reference clone.
Seventy-nine imported P. falciparum infections were recorded: 49 before the earthquake (all in France) and 30 after the earthquake (3 in Canada and 27 in France). The number of confirmed malaria cases imported from Haiti doubled during 2009–2010 (Figure 1). Approximately half of the travelers were in Haiti 2–4 weeks before the earthquake and >1 month after the earthquake. The main purpose of travel, visiting friends and relatives, decreased from 59% before to 44% after the earthquake. More than 75% of travelers did not take prophylactic medication. The proportion of severe malaria increased from 3% to 11% after January 2010 (Table 1).
Before the earthquake, all 29 isolates had the wild-type PfcrtK76 allele according to analysis by PCR–restriction fragment-length polymorphism. The mean 50% inhibitory concentration (IC50) of chloroquine for the 24 isolates tested ex vivo by the 3H-hypoxanthine uptake inhibition method was 27 nM (95% CI 23–31). These results are consistent with those of an unpublished study conducted in Haiti during 2007 to monitor chloroquine resistance (Jean-François Vely, unpub. data). In that study, Haiti’s National Malaria Program, in collaboration with the National Malaria Reference Centre in France, found the chloroquine-sensitive genotype in 146 P. falciparum–positive samples in 6 departments (Artibonite, Centre, Grand’Anse, Nord, Nord-Ouest, Ouest) (Figure 2) (12). After the earthquake, 2 (11%) of 19 isolates analyzed by pyrosequencing and PCR–restriction fragment-length polymorphism showed a mixed Pfcrt76K+T genotype. The ratios of K to T genotypes before and after in vitro adaptation were 0.75:0.25 and 0.23:0.77, respectively, for patient 1, and 0.58:0.42 and 0.25:0.75, respectively, for patient 2. The Pfcrt72–76 haplotype was CVMNK before adaptation and CVIET after adaptation for both patients by sequencing. Resistance was confirmed by in vitro methods after culture adaptation. Both isolates had high chloroquine IC50 (506 nM and 708 nM, respectively) and high chloroquine IC50 isolate:Pf3D7 (chloroquine susceptible clone) ratio (20 and 27, respectively) (Table 2).
Patient 1, a 58-year-old woman, was in Haiti during October 2009–January 2010; she returned after the earthquake to Canada, where she sought care for malaise, fever, diarrhea, and vomiting. She reported no previous malaria and no other travel during the previous 2 years. For patient 2, a 16-year-old girl, malaria was diagnosed in Canada on February 25, 2010, after 3 days of fever. She had traveled to Haiti in the past 2 months before malaria was diagnosed and did not report any other recent travel.
The number of P. falciparum–infected travelers returning from Haiti has increased since January 2010, probably because of the higher number of aid workers and visitors and increased P. falciparum malaria transmission. Data suggest that the earthquake and ensuing hurricane and floods created the necessary conditions—inadequate shelters, population movement, and still water—to increase the incidence of malaria and possibly spread the recently identified chloroquine-resistant strains of P. falciparum (10). In France and Canada, laboratory surveillance for malaria found that 2 travelers from Haiti carried chloroquine-resistant strains. In vitro culture might have selected resistant strains not observed initially by ex vivo methods. After carefully interviewing these patients about their travels, we found no evidence to cause doubt that they had acquired malaria in Haiti. Alternatively, the resistant strains could have come to Haiti after the earthquake through human activity, as occurred in the cholera outbreak (13). The origin of the chloroquine-resistant strains identified in Haiti is uncertain. The Pfcrt CVIET haplotype is common in Southeast Asia and sub-Saharan Africa and was found in the 2006–2007 study in Haiti (10).
Regardless of origin, containing the spread of chloroquine-resistant parasites is crucial. Malaria elimination is a goal in Haiti, and it has been strengthened after recent events, but the effects of malaria and many other factors affect the achievability of this goal (14). Control measures, possibly mirroring those used to contain artemisinin resistance in Southeast Asia, should be concentrated in Haiti to prevent resistance spreading to the rest of Hispaniola (15). However, lack of consensus on the use of molecular and in vitro data for policy change will hamper decision making. Neither the chloroquine-resistant Pfcrt76T genotype nor the elevated chloroquine IC50 perfectly predicts treatment failure because of confounding factors like acquired immunity.
Our study has several limitations. Returning travelers are not a representative sample of the Haitian population, and the sample of isolates was limited. The origin of the resistant strains is not defined. Also, the precise location of infection is not reported. Nevertheless, travelers are useful sentinels of emerging resistance in areas where little information is available, providing surveillance data in real time with standardized methods. This nonimmune population also facilitates detection of resistant isolates.
Our data highlight the need to implement a therapeutic efficacy surveillance study for assessing in vivo chloroquine sensitivity, which is essential for providing information for rational control strategies and guiding prophylaxis recommendations in Haiti. In addition, physicians treating malaria acquired in Haiti should be aware of the possibility of chloroquine-resistant infections. Patients with persistent fever despite treatment and infected travelers reporting adherence to chloroquine prophylaxis should be treated with alternate antimalarial drug therapy.
Dr Gharbi holds a doctoral degree in pharmacy and is pursuing a PhD degree in epidemiology at the Université Pierre et Marie-Curie, Paris. Her primary research interest is the epidemiology of antimalarial drug resistance.
Members of the French National Reference Center for Imported Malaria Study who contributed to this article: Amhed Aboubacar, Patrice Agnamey, Adela Angoulvant, Didier Basset, Ghania Belkadi, Anne-Pauline Bellanger, Dieudonné Bemba, Françoise Benoit-Vical, Antoine Berry, Olivier Bouchaud, Patrice Bourée, Bernadette Buret, Enrique Casalino, Frédérique Conquere de Monbrison, Martin Danis, Pascal Delaunay, Anne Delaval, Michel Develoux, Jean Dunand, Remy Durand, Odile Eloy, Madeleine Fontrouge, Françoise Gayandrieu, Nadine Godineau, Céline Gourmel, Samia Hamane, Sandrine Houze, Houria Ichou, Anne-Sophie Le Guern, Anne Marfaing Koka, Denis Mechali, Bruno Megarbane, Olivier Patey, Isabelle Poilane, Denis Pons, Bruno Pradines, Christophe Rapp, Marie-Catherine Receveur, Claudine Sarfati, Jean-Yves Siriez, Marc Thellier, and Michel Thibault.
We thank Valerie Tate for critical reading of the manuscript and Vely Jean-François (deceased) for his contribution to the study.
This study was supported in part by a grant for doctoral studies to M.G. from the Doctoral Network of the École des Hautes Études en Santé Publique, Rennes, France.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Malaria acquired in Haiti, 2010. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2010;59:217–9.
- Eisele TP, Keating J, Bennett A, Londono B, Johnson D, Lafontant C, Prevalence of Plasmodium falciparum infection in rainy season, Artibonite Valley, Haiti, 2006. Emerg Infect Dis. 2007;13:1494–6.
- Bonnlander H, Rossignol AM, Rossignol PA. Malaria in central Haiti: a hospital-based retrospective study, 1982–1986 and 1988–1991. Bull Pan Am Health Organ. 1994;28:9–16.
- Mason J, Cavalie P. Malaria epidemic in Haiti following a hurricane. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1965;14:533–9.
- Townes D, Existe A, Boncy J, Magloire R, Vely JF, Amsalu R, Malaria survey in post-earthquake Haiti—2010. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2012;86:29–31.
- Neuberger A, Zaulan O, Tenenboim S, Vernet S, Pex R, Held K, Malaria among patients and aid workers consulting a primary healthcare centre in Leogane, Haiti, November 2010 to February 2011—a prospective observational study. Euro Surveill. 2011;16:pii:19829.
- Agarwal A, McMorrow M, Arguin PM. The increase of imported malaria acquired in Haiti among US travelers in 2010. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2012;86:9–10.
- Duverseau YT, Magloire R, Zevallos-Ipenza A, Rogers HM, Nguyen-Dinh P. Monitoring of chloroquine sensitivity of Plasmodium falciparum in Haiti, 1981–1983. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1986;35:459–64.
- Drabick JJ, Gambel JM, Huck E, De Young S, Hardeman L. Microbiological laboratory results from Haiti: June–October 1995. Bull World Health Organ. 1997;75:109–15.
- Londono BL, Eisele TP, Keating J, Bennett A, Chattopadhyay C, Heyliger G, Chloroquine-resistant haplotype Plasmodium falciparum parasites, Haiti. Emerg Infect Dis. 2009;15:735–40.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Malaria: Haiti pre-decision brief for public health action [cited 2010 Apr 23]. http://emergency.cdc.gov/disasters/earthquakes/haiti/malaria_pre-decision_brief.asp
- Maïga-Ascofaré O, Le Bras J, Mazmouz R, Renard E, Falcão S, Broussier E, Adaptive differentiation of Plasmodium falciparum populations inferred from single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) conferring drug resistance and from neutral SNPs. J Infect Dis. 2010;202:1095–103.
- Chin CS, Sorenson J, Harris JB, Robins WP, Charles RC, Jean-Charles RR, The origin of the Haitian cholera outbreak. N Engl J Med. 2011;364:33–42.
- Feachem RGA, Phillips AA, Hwang J, Cotter C, Wielgosz B, Greenwood BM, Shrinking the malaria map: progress and prospects. Lancet. 2010;376:1566–78.
- World Health Organization. Global plan for artemisinin resistance containment (GPARC). Geneva: The Organization; 2011.
Suggested citation for this article: Gharbi M, Pillai DR, Lau R, HubertV, Khairnar K, Existe A, et al. Chloroquine-resistant malaria in travelers returning from Haiti after 2010 earthquake. Emerg Infect Dis [serial on the Internet]. 2012 Aug [date cited]. http://dx.doi.org/10.3201/eid1808.111779
1Members of the French National Reference Center for Imported Malaria Study who contributed data are listed at the end of this article.
Comments to the Authors
Lessons from the History of Quarantine, from Plague to Influenza A