Skip directly to site content Skip directly to page options Skip directly to A-Z link Skip directly to A-Z link Skip directly to A-Z link
Volume 22, Number 11—November 2016
Letter

Travel-Associated Vibrio cholerae O1 El Tor, Russia

Cite This Article

To the Editor: Cholera—a severe, waterborne, virulent enteric infection caused by toxigenic strains of Vibrio cholera—frequently causes epidemics in developing countries and sporadic cases or local outbreaks in developed countries. The geographic features of Russia and intensive globalization have established favorable conditions for travel-associated cholera from regions to which it is endemic. During 2005–2012, six such cases occurred in Russia; these cases were related to travel from India. Three of the cases were registered in 2010, three months before the cholera outbreak in Haiti, one of the most extensive outbreaks in recent history (1). We genetically analyzed 4 isolates collected in 2010 and 2012 using whole-genome sequencing (Technical Appendix 1) and compared the results with a public database of representative V. cholerae strains (Technical Appendix 2) to identify whether these isolates were linked to cholera in Haiti and Nepal.

Isolate RND6878 was isolated on July 7, 2012 from a 28-year-old male Russian citizen. The infection was most likely caused by the patient drinking fountain water and coming into contact with river water while living in Srinagar, India. Isolate RND19191 originated from a 25-year-old female flight attendant operating a Moscow–Delhi–Moscow flight. Her infection was suspected to have occurred in Delhi during June 26–28, 2010, from ingestion of contaminated fruit. Isolate RND19187 was obtained on June 9, 2010, from a 29-year-old woman with severe cholera. Microbiological testing also confirmed the presence of V. cholerae in a fecal specimen from her 10-month-old daughter (isolate RND19188), even though she had no distinct symptoms of cholera. The source of infection for the woman and child was unclear but was assumed to be related to eating fruit rinsed in tap water while in the city of Vrindavan in India.

Figure

Thumbnail of Maximum-likelihood tree based on an orthologous 193-nt–long high-quality orthologous single-nucleotide polymorphism (hqSNP) matrix of 75 Vibrio cholerae O1 El Tor genomes using the general time-reversible model, withestimation of invariant sites. The phylogenetic tree shows clustering of strains isolated from travel-associated cases of V. cholerae O1 El Tor (asterisks) with isolates collected worldwide. The CIRS101 genome was used as the outgroup. The numbers above nodes represent a

Figure. Maximum-likelihood tree based on an orthologous 193-nt–long high-quality orthologous single-nucleotide polymorphism (hqSNP) matrix of 75 Vibrio cholerae O1 El Tor genomes using the general time-reversible model, withestimation of invariant sites. The...

Maximum-likelihood phylogenetic analysis based on high-quality orthologous single-nucleotide polymorphisms (hqSNPs) among 75 V. cholerae genomes showed that all the isolates from the travel-associated cases clustered with cholera cases that occurred in 2010. The isolates from the 29-year-old woman and her daughter (RND19187 and RND19188) accurately clustered with isolates from the Nepal-3 clade (2) (Figure). Isolate RND19187 exhibited no hqSNP differences from VC-15 and differed from VC-18 by only 1 hqSNP. Isolate RND19191 was located in the Haiti\Nepal-4 clade and differed by only 1 hqSNP (132291G>A), located in the integrative and conjugative element encodes resistance to sulfametoxazol and trimethoprim (SXT-ICE) gene Vch1786-I0110 (Figure). RND19191 and 2010EL-1786 showed high genetic similarity and nucleotide identity to Vibrio pathogenic islands (VPI-1, VPI-2), Vibrio seventh pandemic islands (VSP-I, VSP-II), and SXT-ICE (Technical Appendix 3). Notably, isolate RND19191 has intact SXT-ICE, whereas all 3 Nepal-4 genomes have an SXT-ICE 13-gene deletion (Vch1786_I0089-I0102) (3). This genome also carries a ctxB7 variant of the ctxB gene and five 7-mer tandem repeats (TTTTGAT). Finally, isolate RND6878 and the Haiti/Nepal-4 clade formed a well-supported monophyletic group with an estimated most recent common ancestor date of 2009 (95% CI 2008–2010) (Figure). In addition, the RND6878 genome harbored virulence-associated mobile genomic elements similar to 2010EL-1786 and contained a ctxB7 allele and an intact SXT-ICE, but only four 7-mer tandem repeats (TTTTGAT).

The phylogenetic relatedness between the India and Nepal strains shows that the strains similar to the latter were first found in northern India not far from the frontier of Nepal. Collectively, these data support previously established assumptions that V. cholerae strains similar to those from Nepal can be detected in countries other than Nepal and Haiti (2). Moreover, isolate RND6878, which is phylogenetically related to the Haiti/Nepal-4 clade and was isolated in 2012, might have a common genetic lineage with the Haiti-like strains found in Nepal and northern India since 2009 (Figure). However, sequencing of representative strains isolated from different geographic regions and varying time frames is needed to reconstruct this lineage.

Remarkably, an India isolate (RND19191) from 3 months before the first cholera cases occurred in Haiti showed higher genetic similarity to the Haiti strain than Nepal isolate VC-25. This finding should be interpreted with caution because this study was limited to the analysis of only 1 isolate, with no epidemiologic context to link the isolate to the Haiti or Nepal outbreaks. Thus, India could not be validated as a primary source of Haiti strains, and the existence of a direct transmission route from India to Haiti that does not involve Nepal could not be substantiated. It is generally accepted on the basis of epidemiologic data and molecular phylogenetics that the Haiti strain was introduced from Nepal (2,4). Thus, epidemiologic studies remain critical for defining an outbreak’s origin, especially when a pathogen is rapidly disseminated by its host. This is true even when modern molecular subtyping methods, such as whole-genome sequencing, offer highly resolved phylogenetic insights.

Top

Konstantin V. KuleshovComments to Author , Sergey O. Vodop’ianov, Vladimir G. Dedkov, Mikhail L. Markelov, Andrey A. Deviatkin, Vladimir D. Kruglikov, Alexey S. Vodop’ianov, Ruslan V. Pisanov, Alexey B. Mazrukho, Svetlana V. Titova, Victor V. Maleev, and German A. Shipulin

Author affiliations: Federal Budget Institute of Science Central Research Institute for Epidemiology, Moscow, Russia (K.V. Kuleshov, V.G. Dedkov, A.A. Deviatkin, V.V. Maleev, G.A. Shipulin); Federal Government Health Institution Rostov-on-Don Plague Control Research Institute, Rostov-on-Don, Russia (S.O. Vodop’ianov, V.D. Kruglikov, A.S. Vodop’ianov, R.V. Pisanov, A.B. Mazrukho, S.V. Titova); Research Institute of Occupational Health, Moscow (M.L. Markelov); Federal Budget Institute Chumakov Institute of Poliomyelitis and Viral Encephalitides, Moscow (A.A. Deviatkin)

Top

References

  1. Barzilay  EJ, Schaad  N, Magloire  R, Mung  KS, Boncy  J, Dahourou  GA, Cholera surveillance during the Haiti epidemic—the first 2 years. N Engl J Med. 2013;368:599609.DOIPubMed
  2. Hendriksen  RS, Price  LB, Schupp  JM, Gillece  JD, Kaas  RS, Engelthaler  DM, Population genetics of Vibrio cholerae from Nepal in 2010: evidence on the origin of the Haitian outbreak. MBio. 2011;2:e0015711.DOIPubMed
  3. Katz  LS, Petkau  A, Beaulaurier  J, Tyler  S, Antonova  ES, Turnsek  MA, Evolutionary dynamics of Vibrio cholerae O1 following a single-source introduction to Haiti. MBio. 2013;4:e0039813.DOIPubMed
  4. Lantagne  D, Balakrish Nair  G, Lanata  CF, Cravioto  A. The cholera outbreak in Haiti: where and how did it begin? Curr Top Microbiol Immunol. 2014;379:14564.DOIPubMed

Top

Figure

Top

Cite This Article

DOI: 10.3201/eid2211.151727

Related Links

Top

Table of Contents – Volume 22, Number 11—November 2016

Comments

Please use the form below to submit correspondence to the authors or contact them at the following address:

Konstantin V. Kuleshov, Federal Budget Institute of Science Central Research Institute for Epidemiology—Laboratory of Molecular Diagnostic and Epidemiology of Enteric Infections, Novogireevskaya St, 3A Moscow 111123, Russia

Send To

character(s) remaining.

Comment submitted successfully, thank you for your feedback.

Top

Page created: October 19, 2016
Page updated: October 19, 2016
Page reviewed: October 19, 2016
The conclusions, findings, and opinions expressed by authors contributing to this journal do not necessarily reflect the official position of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, the Public Health Service, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, or the authors' affiliated institutions. Use of trade names is for identification only and does not imply endorsement by any of the groups named above.
file_external