Volume 23, Number 10—October 2017
Economic Assessment of Waterborne Outbreak of Cryptosporidiosis
Highlight and copy the desired format.
|EID||Chyzheuskaya A, Cormican M, Srivinas R, O’Donovan D, Prendergast M, O’Donoghue C, et al. Economic Assessment of Waterborne Outbreak of Cryptosporidiosis. Emerg Infect Dis. 2017;23(10):1650-1656. https://dx.doi.org/10.3201/eid2310.152037|
|AMA||Chyzheuskaya A, Cormican M, Srivinas R, et al. Economic Assessment of Waterborne Outbreak of Cryptosporidiosis. Emerging Infectious Diseases. 2017;23(10):1650-1656. doi:10.3201/eid2310.152037.|
|APA||Chyzheuskaya, A., Cormican, M., Srivinas, R., O’Donovan, D., Prendergast, M., O’Donoghue, C....Morris, D. (2017). Economic Assessment of Waterborne Outbreak of Cryptosporidiosis. Emerging Infectious Diseases, 23(10), 1650-1656. https://dx.doi.org/10.3201/eid2310.152037.|
In 2007, a waterborne outbreak of Cryptosporidium hominis infection occurred in western Ireland, resulting in 242 laboratory-confirmed cases and an uncertain number of unconfirmed cases. A boil water notice was in place for 158 days that affected 120,432 persons residing in the area, businesses, visitors, and commuters. This outbreak represented the largest outbreak of cryptosporidiosis in Ireland. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the cost of this outbreak. We adopted a societal perspective in estimating costs associated with the outbreak. Economic cost estimated was based on totaling direct and indirect costs incurred by public and private agencies. The cost of the outbreak was estimated based on 2007 figures. We estimate that the cost of the outbreak was >€19 million (≈€120,000/day of the outbreak). The US dollar equivalent based on today’s exchange rates would be $22.44 million (≈$142,000/day of the outbreak). This study highlights the economic need for a safe drinking water supply.
Cryptosporidium spp. are protozoan parasites that might be present in inadequately treated water. Human infection can result in watery diarrhea, stomach cramps, bloating, vomiting, and fever (1–3). Although usually a self-limiting illness in otherwise healthy persons, cryptosporidiosis might be associated with chronic gastrointestinal sequelae in some persons and might be fatal for persons with impaired immune function (4). In Ireland, animal contact is the main source of transmission (5). Endemic disease usually occurs in the spring, is predominantly rural, and is generally associated with C. parvum (4,6). C. hominis is primarily a parasite of primates, including humans, and is less common in Ireland.
Several large waterborne outbreaks of cryptosporidiosis have been reported (5,7,8). In 1993, contamination of the municipal water supply affected an estimated 403,000 persons in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA (7). In March 2001 in North Battleford, Saskatchewan, Canada, an estimated 7,000 persons became ill from contaminated water (9).
Many studies have estimated the economic costs of microbial contamination of drinking water supplies (7,10–13). However, there is no standard method for performing such analysis. Halonen et al. estimated the cost of the lost workdays to be €1.8–2.1 million (11). Corso et al. included medical costs and loss of productivity related to cryptosporidiosis in Milwaukee and estimated the costs to be $96.2 million (7). A similar approach was used in a study in Canada by the Safe Drinking Water Foundation (Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada) in 2015, whichconducted a full cost-benefit analysis of microbial contamination of the water supply in Walkerton, Ontario (13). Regardless of the approach used by researchers, there is agreement that costs of outbreaks are considerable and that benefits of preventive measures need to be investigated (11–13).
Outbreaks of cryptosporidiosis are common in Ireland. During 2011–2014, a total of 100 outbreaks (84 of which were outbreaks in families) were reported that included 305 cases (5). In March 2007, the largest outbreak of cryptosporidiosis in Ireland since surveillance began was identified and was associated with contamination of the public water supply serving an urban area (Galway, Ireland) and surrounding areas. The outbreak was distinguished from the usual spring peak not only by the number of cases but also by the predominantly urban distribution and the infecting species (C. hominis). The outbreak lasted for 5 months, by which time there were 242 confirmed cases of cryptosporidiosis (Health Service Executive [HSE], Galway, Ireland, unpub. data), although it was likely that the actual number affected was higher (14). A boil water notice was put in place for the duration of the outbreak (158 days); the order affected ≈120,432 persons. The outbreak ended in August 2007 after major investments by local authorities in water treatment infrastructure and major disruption to residents and local businesses.
Water quality incidents, such as the outbreak of cryptosporidiosis in Galway in 2007, can have major economic effects on the entire community (residential and commercial) (7,15). The challenge associated with managing waterborne infection with Cryptosporidium spp. is that infection is not inactivated by chlorination of water, which is the primary method of water treatment in many areas (6). Several technologies are available to remove or inactivate Cryptosporidium spp. during water treatment. These technologies include filtration and ultraviolet light treatment systems.
We assessed economic costs associated with the waterborne outbreak of cryptosporidiosis in Galway, Ireland, during 2007 from the societal perspective. Assessment of costs included not only costs incurred by the 242 reported cases but costs incurred by persons who were ill but did not seek healthcare, as well as by the wider public, local businesses, the healthcare system, local authorities, national agencies, and tourism. We also examined the ratio between the investment needed to mitigate risk for contamination with Cryptosporidium spp. and costs averted by such an investment. The aim of such analysis was to aid decision makers with public investment decisions and to inform other stakeholders about economic consequences associated with outbreaks of this type.
A societal perspective was adopted in estimating costs associated with this outbreak. The costs associated with the waterborne outbreak of cryptosporidiosis in Galway in 2007 have a multilevel structure (Figure). Consistent with previous research and traditional health economic frameworks, we included direct and indirect costs in calculations (15). Direct costs were medical and healthcare costs, cost of provision of alternative water, and response costs. Indirect costs were loss of income, loss of business, and loss of productivity (15). We describe the economic effect of the outbreak on those directly affected, and in the wider community, local businesses, and government agencies. The economic cost estimated in our analysis is based on totaling direct and indirect costs incurred by public and private economic agencies (Figure) associated with the outbreak.
Costs included are consistent with those included in previous economic assessments of waterborne outbreaks of infectious diseases (7,15,16). In our analysis, most costs are reported to have occurred during the outbreak in 2007. Thus, use of a discount rate was not considered necessary. Although the final update was completed in 2009, we could not differentiate what proportion of this update occurred in what period. Thus, the value for the update that was provided to us was not discounted.
Data Sources and Assumptions
Data, sources, and assumptions (if any) made in estimating costs are provided (Table 1). To estimate household costs, we used data for the Simulation Model of the Irish Local Economy (SMILE) (17) to determine the number of households and their socioeconomic characteristics if located in the boil water notice area. SMILE (17) is a synthetic dataset that is spatially representative of households and farms at an electoral district level and includes several datasets (e.g., the Living in Ireland Survey, Small Population Statistics, and the Geo-Directory) (16).
In the context of this analysis, we used SMILE data for 2006. On the basis of these data, there were 45,160 households in the area containing 120,432 persons, which included 5,034 children <5 years of age, 13,471 children >5–<18 years of age, 87,970 adults <65 years of age, and 13 persons >65 years of age.
Not Reported Case-Patients
Many studies have reported variation in the number of not reported cases of gastroenteritis in outbreak settings (7,14–15). Fitzgerald et al. reported that 71% of persons with gastroenteritis whose health was affected were not reported as case-patients (14). Corso et al. estimated that during the outbreak of cryptosporidiosis in Milwaukee in 1993, a total of 25% of the population in the area were affected, but 88% of them were not reported (7). If the estimate of 25% of the population is applied in this study, the estimated number of cases not reported would have been 25,291.
For our economic assessment, we adopted a more conservative approach and assumed that 71% of persons with signs or symptoms were not reported as case-patients. In addition, we assumed that cases not reported would be in less vulnerable persons 5–64 years of age (≈101,441 persons or 84% of total population in the area estimated by using SMILE data). Therefore, on the basis of the number of reported cases, we estimated that 498 persons who were ill did not seek healthcare or were not reported. The costs we estimated are based on the most conservative figure, but we acknowledge that there is substantial uncertainty regarding the number of persons infected, and the actual number infected may be >498 persons.
We assumed that all confirmed case-patients visited a general practitioner at least once (estimated cost/visit €50). The same cost was assigned to all private patients, public patients, or general medical services patients because general medical services general practitioners claim for out-of-house services is €50.64 (HSE primary care reimbursement service data for 2008). We assumed that 30% of reported case-patients and 17.6% of not reported case-patients self-medicated (7) with an antidiarrheal agent and an oral rehydration solution. We also assumed that each self-medicated case-patient purchased 1 packet of antidiarrheal medication and 1 packet of oral rehydration solution (Table 1).
Shortly after the outbreak, the HSE Western Area (Limerick, Ireland) commissioned Ipsos MORI (London, UK), a private marketing research company, to conduct a postoutbreak survey to determine the effect of the outbreak on residents of the area affected by the boil water notice and for persons visiting the area for work or recreational activities (commuters and tourists). Results of this survey were available, and we used these results in our economic assessment. The survey found that all nonhospitalized reported cases-patients and 17.4% of not reported case-patients missed on average 5 days of work, and those who were hospitalized (35% of reported case-patients) were absent from work for an average of 10 days. Because of uncertainty about employment status and sector of persons under consideration, we assumed that all persons 22–65 years of age were employed, received an average industrial wage, and were not paid for days of work missed because of illness (HSE, 2007, unpub. data).
We assumed that dependents (189 symptomatic children <15 years of age and 6 elderly persons >65 years of age) would require a full-time caregiver for the duration of their illness (5 days for nonhospitalized case-patients and 10 days for hospitalized cases-patients). Loss of income (for reported and not reported case patients) was estimated as the average industrial wage rate in Ireland in 2007 (€122.85/d for 2007; Central Statistics Office, Cork, Ireland). Moreover, persons <21 years of age (reported and not reported case-patients) were assumed to either attend college/school or were unemployed. Consistent with previous research by Safefood (16), we assigned the opportunity cost to the time they were ill at the minimum wage rate in 2007 (≈€69.20/d for 2007; Central Statistics Office).
On the basis of the Ipsos MORI survey results, we assumed that 48% of households bought extra bottled water, 80% increased bottled water consumption from 3.2 L/wk to 16.1 L/wk, and the remaining 20% increased consumption from 3.2 L/wk to 20 L/wk, at a cost of €0.50/L of bottled water purchased. On the basis of the study by Ailes et al. (15), we assumed that 12% of households boiled water for drinking, 30% for cooking, 43% for dishwashing, and 14% for hygiene use, at a cost of €0.01/L. This cost was based on National Electricity Supply Board (Dublin, Ireland) tariffs reported in 2007 and energy required. Further assumptions about the number of liters boiled for each purpose are provided (Table 1).
Public Sector Costs
We made assumptions related to costs incurred by the public sector. These assumptions include cost of emergency department attendance, which is assumed to apply to 1.3% of reported case-patients (14) (€100/visit, which is usually charged to private patients in Ireland (HSE data); cost of a hospital stay (€753/d reported by the HSE in 2015); costs incurred by local authorities (Galway City Council €3,388,840.33 and Galway County Council €2,472,837); cost of the response team (28 meetings attended by 16 senior representatives of HSE West, Galway County Council, and Galway City Council representing an estimated opportunity cost of €356/person/meeting); and costs incurred by the Environmental Protection Agency (Dublin, Ireland), which were estimated to be €20,000.
Private Sector Costs
Costs to the private business sector in the area proved to be more challenging to estimate because of lack of available data. It proved particularly difficult to obtain reliable data on costs incurred by restaurants. Therefore, we excluded these costs from calculations. The remaining business costs (service sector [lodging businesses] and care sector [nurseries, child care, nursing homes]), sources, and assumptions are provided (Table 1).
We estimated that the overall cost of the waterborne outbreak of cryptosporidiosis in Galway in 2007 was €19 million or €120,000/day of the outbreak (Table 2). The US dollar equivalent based on today’s exchange rates would be $22.44 million (≈$142,000/day of the outbreak). The estimated cost to households in the affected area was ≈€3.9 million. This estimate translates into an average cost of alternative water of ≈€87/household in the boil water notice zone (or €0.55/household/day of the outbreak). The overall loss of income to households with symptomatic persons was estimated to be €287,957. This cost includes the loss of income of ill persons and their caregivers. The cost for not reported case-patients was estimated to be €74,002. If the average household income in the boil water zone was estimated to be €27,251/year (as estimated by using SMILE data) or €11,796 in 158 days, the loss translates into 0.8% of household income in the affected area during the outbreak.
We estimated that cost for lodging and care businesses was €8 million (€50,000 lost by local businesses/day of the outbreak). We also estimated that businesses in the lodging sector lost €5.4 million because of cancellations and an additional €1.7 million required for provision of alternative water to customers. Care businesses provided alternative water to persons in their care at an estimated cost of €525,929.
The waterborne outbreak of cryptosporidiosis that occurred in Galway in 2007 resulted in 242 reported cases of illness and a conservative estimate of 498 additional cases that were not reported. This outbreak also generated a considerable cost to residents, visitors, public bodies, and local businesses. This study highlights the economic need for a safe drinking water supply by reporting public expenditure on mitigating results of the outbreak and private costs to households and businesses in the area. The outbreak was believed to have occurred because the lake that serves as the source of drinking water for the city became contaminated with C. hominis, and the treatment process in place was not sufficient to eliminate or inactivate the parasite before water was distributed in the municipal supply.
Our results indicated that there are economic benefits of investing in safe drinking water supplies and water treatment enhancement (e.g., treatment with UV light, which effectively inactivates Cryptosporidium oocysts) (19,20). Hutton et al. reported a return of $5–$46 per $1 investment in water and sanitation improvements: all water improvement interventions examined in their study were cost-beneficial (12).
We recognize a major limitation in our approach to assessing relative costs. There is uncertainty associated with number of reported and not reported cases. The outbreak was the largest reported in Ireland, but other studies support the conclusion that when public water supply is contaminated with C. hominis, large proportions of populations are affected (7,21). There is also no basis on which to estimate the frequency with which a source water contamination event likely to result in a comparable outbreak occurs. If such a contamination event occurs frequently (e.g., annually), the cost of implementation greatly outweighs the associated costs of infection. If such an event occurs every 100 years, then the situation might be reversed. In the context of a municipal supply based on a large surface water body in which source protection is challenging, we believe contamination is likely to occur relatively frequently. Methods to define the annual probability of a major contamination event for a particular water supply more precisely would be of value.
Costs assessed for this evaluation related to the period of an outbreak. However, there is reason to believe that some economic impacts continued for years afterward related to the undermining of public trust in the water supply and affected Galway area and local businesses because of reduced numbers of visitors. As many as 13% of respondents to the Ipsos MORI survey indicated that they were less likely to return to the Galway area because of the outbreak. Thus, the economic effect might be greater.
Limited data is one of the obstacles that resulted in the number of assumptions made in this study. Thus, our results should be interpreted carefully, and we advise careful examination of assumptions before drawing conclusions. The lack of data related to businesses in the area and the effect of the outbreak on business operations prevented us from accounting for these effects in our calculations. Moreover, there is an uncertainty about the number of persons who were ill as a result of the outbreak, but did not seek help.
We estimated that the overall cost of this outbreak was €19 million (€120,000/day of the outbreak). These findings strongly support the value of a sustainable economic model to ensure that water infrastructure upgrades anticipate and prevent outbreaks. This study identified that availability of appropriate data are a limiting factor in completion of such economic assessments and provided valuable evidence that investment in safe drinking water supplies and water treatment enhancement benefits public health and the wider economy.
Dr. Chyzheuskaya is a postdoctoral researcher and lecturer (Economics) at the Centre for Global Women’s Studies, National University of Ireland Galway, Galway, Ireland. Her research interests are environmental economics, economics of water pollution, agricultural economics, microsimulation modeling, macroeconomic modeling, bioeconomic modeling, and policy evaluation.
We thank all relevant representatives of the Galway County Council, Galway City Council, Health Service Executive, and the Environmental Protection Agency of Ireland for providing data.
This study was supported by the Environmental Protection Agency of Ireland as part of the Research Programme 2014–2020.
- Dietz V, Vugia D, Nelson R, Wicklund J, Nadle J, McCombs KG, et al. Active, multisite, laboratory-based surveillance for Cryptosporidium parvum. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2000;62:368–72.
- Mead PS, Slutsker L, Dietz V, McCaig LF, Bresee JS, Shapiro C, et al. Food-related illness and death in the United States. Emerg Infect Dis. 1999;5:607–25.
- Vijgen SM, Mangen MJ, Ortbeek LM, van Duijnhoven YT, Havelaar AH. Disease burden and related costs of cryptosporidiosis and giardiasis in the Netherlands. RIVM report 330081001, 2007 [cited 2016 Aug 9]. http://www.researchgate.net/publication/27453554_Disease_burden_and_related_costs_of_cryptosporidiosis_and_giardiasis_in_the_Netherlands
- Garvey P, McKeown P. Epidemiology of cryptosporidiosis in Ireland, 2007. Health Protection Surveillance Centre. Annual report 2007. 2008 [cited 2016 Aug 9]. http://www.hpsc.ie/A-Z/Gastroenteric/Cryptosporidiosis/Publications/EpidemiologyofCryptosporidiosisinIrelandAnnualReports/File,3475,en.pdf
- Health Protection Surveillance Centre. HPSC annual epidemiological reports on cryptosporidiosis in Ireland [Cited 2016 Aug 9]. http://www.hpsc.ie/A-Z/Gastroenteric/Cryptosporidiosis/Publications/EpidemiologyofCryptosporidiosisinIrelandAnualReports/
- Callaghan M, Cormican M, Prendergast M, Pelly H, Cloughley R, Hanahoe B, et al. Temporal and spatial distribution of human cryptosporidiosis in the west of Ireland 2004-2007. Int J Health Geogr. 2009;8:64.
- Corso PS, Kramer MH, Blair KA, Addiss DG, Davis JP, Haddix AC. Cost of illness in the 1993 waterborne Cryptosporidium outbreak, Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Emerg Infect Dis. 2003;9:426–31.
- Bridge JW, Oliver DM, Chadwick D, Godfray HC, Heathwaite AL, Kay D, et al. Engaging with the water sector for public health benefits: waterborne pathogens and diseases in developed countries. Bull World Health Organ. 2010;88:873–5.
- Jameson PB, Hung YT, Kuo CY, Bosela PA. Cryptosporidium outbreak (water treatment failure): North Battleford, Saskatchewan, spring, 2001. J Perform Constr Facil. 2008;22:342–7.
- Pelly H, Cormican M, O’Donovan D, Chalmers RM, Hanahoe B, Cloughley R, et al. A large outbreak of cryptosporidiosis in western Ireland linked to public water supply: a preliminary report. Euro Surveill. 2007;12:E070503.3.
- Halonen JI, Kivimäki M, Oksanen T, Virtanen P, Virtanen MJ, Pentti J, et al. Waterborne outbreak of gastroenteritis: effects on sick leaves and cost of lost workdays. PLoS One. 2012;7:e33307.
- Hutton G, Haller L, Bartram J. Global cost-benefit analysis of water supply and sanitation interventions. J Water Health. 2007;5:481–502.
- Safe Drinking Water Foundation. Cost-benefit analysis: treat the illness or treat the water? [cited 2016 Aug 9]. http://www.safewater.org/PDFS/resourcesknowthefacts/CostBenefit_Analysis_Treat.pdf
- Ailes E, Budge P, Shankar M, Collier S, Brinton W, Cronquist A, et al. Economic and health impacts associated with a Salmonella Typhimurium drinking water outbreak-Alamosa, CO, 2008. PLoS One. 2013;8:e57439.
- Fitzgerald M, Scallen E, Collins C, Crowley D, Daly L, Devine M, et al. Results of the first population based telephone survey of acute gastroenteritis in Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. Euro Surveill. 2004;8:2456.
- Safefood. Acute gastroenteritis in Ireland: a telephone survey. Research report September 2003 [cited 2016 Aug 9]. http://www.safefood.eu/SafeFood/media/SafeFoodLibrary/Documents/Publications/Research%20Reports/Acute_Gastroenteritis.pdf
- O’Donoghue C, Ballas D, Clarke G, Hynes S, Morrissey K. Spatial microsimulation for rural policy analysis: Berlin: Springer; 2012.
- The Sphere Project. The sphere handbook: humanitarian charter and minimum standards in humanitarian response; 2011 [cited 2016 Aug 9] http://www.sphereproject.org/resources/?search=1&keywords=&language=English&category=22&subcat-22=23&subcat-29=0&subcat-31=0&subcat-35=0&subcat-49=0
- Garvey M, Farrell H, Cormican M, Rowan N. Investigations of the relationship between use of in vitro cell culture-quantitative PCR and a mouse-based bioassay for evaluating critical factors affecting the disinfection performance of pulsed UV light for treating Cryptosporidium parvum oocysts in saline. J Microbiol Methods. 2010;80:267–73.
- Zimmer JL, Slawson RM, Huck PM. Inactivation and potential repair of Cryptosporidium parvum following low- and medium-pressure ultraviolet irradiation. Water Res. 2003;37:3517–23.
- Widerström M, Schönning C, Lilja M, Lebbad M, Ljung T, Allestam G, et al. Large outbreak of Cryptosporidium hominis infection transmitted through the public water supply, Sweden. Emerg Infect Dis. 2014;20:581–9.
TablesCite This Article
- Page created: September 18, 2017
- Page last updated: September 18, 2017
- Page last reviewed: September 18, 2017
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases (NCEZID)
Office of the Director (OD)