Disclaimer: Early release articles are not considered as final versions. Any changes will be reflected in the online version in the month the article is officially released.
Volume 28, Supplement—October 2022
Faith Community Engagement to Mitigate COVID-19 Transmission Associated with Mass Gathering, Uman, Ukraine, September 2021
Annually, ≈30,000 Hasidic and Orthodox Jews travel to Uman, Ukraine, during the Jewish New Year to pray at the burial place of the founder of the Breslov Hasidic movement. Many pilgrims come from the northeastern United States. The global health implications of this event were seen in 2019 when measles outbreaks in the United States and Israel were linked to the pilgrimage. The 2020 pilgrimage was cancelled as part of the COVID-19 travel restrictions imposed by the government of Ukraine. To prepare for the 2021 event, the National Public Health Institute, the Public Health Center of Ukraine, organized mitigation measures for pilgrims arriving in Uman, and the CDC COVID-19 International Task Force assisted with mitigation measures for pilgrims coming from the United States. We describe efforts to support COVID-19 mitigation measures before, during, and after this mass gathering and lessons learned for future mass gatherings during pandemics.
The World Health Organization (WHO) characterized the spread of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, as a pandemic in March 2020 (1). At the onset of the pandemic, WHO recognized transmission risks during gatherings and subsequently issued guidance and policy documents for gatherings during the COVID-19 pandemic (2). Mass gatherings are defined by WHO as events involving large numbers of attendees at a specific location, for a specific purpose, over a specific duration of time (3). Given the high density and mobility of participants, mass gatherings can be associated with increased transmission of SARS-CoV-2. These gatherings can create conditions conducive for SARS-CoV-2 transmission, given crowding, challenges with physical distancing, and prolonged and frequent contact among mass gathering participants. Therefore, the WHO recommended that, during the pandemic, gatherings “should not take place unless the basic precautionary measures to prevent and control infection are strictly applied and adhered to by all attendees” (2). These basic precautionary measures include physical distancing, regular handwashing, adherence to mask guidance issued by local health authorities, staying outdoors and avoiding crowding, and ensuring proper ventilation when indoors.
Orthodox Jewish communities in New York City (NYC), New York, USA, have been disproportionally affected by COVID-19. In the early fall of 2020, the incidence of COVID-19 in Orthodox Jewish neighborhoods was 4 times higher than the citywide average (4). As of April 2020, the Hasidic neighborhood of Borough Park in Brooklyn had the second-highest number of COVID-19 cases in NYC, and the predominantly Orthodox County of Rockland County, New York, experienced the second-highest number of COVID-19 cases per capita in the United States (5).
Each year, ≈30,000 Hasidic and other Orthodox Jews travel to Uman, a city that has 86,900 persons in the Cherkasy Region of central Ukraine, during the Jewish new year, Rosh Hashanah, and subsequent high holy days, as part of a pilgrimage to pray at the burial place of Rabbi Nachman, an 18th century luminary who founded the Breslov Hasidic movement (6). During the Uman pilgrimage, pilgrims gather in tight quarters when praying in synagogues, as well as when sleeping and eating. Thousands of pilgrims travel to Uman from the United States, particularly from NYC (Amudim Community Resources, https://amudim.org). The global health implications of this event were seen in 2019 when measles outbreaks in the United States and Israel were linked to the pilgrimage (7,8). Cases of infection with SARS-CoV-2 in Ukraine were reported during in March 2020 (9).
As of September 6, 2021, the beginning of Rosh Hashanah, 2,578,394 SARS-CoV-2 cases and 59,523 deaths had been reported in Ukraine (10). As part of the travel restrictions put in place by the government of Ukraine to prevent the spread of COVID-19, international travelers were not allowed to enter the country for the Uman pilgrimage in 2020 (11). Travel restrictions were lifted in 2021, enabling international travelers to participate in the Rosh Hashanah pilgrimage during September 6–8, 2021. Many pilgrims remained in Uman throughout the Jewish High Holidays that ended on September 29, 2021. Given the disruption of the 2020 pilgrimage, a larger number of pilgrims was expected for the 2021 Uman pilgrimage.
The Ukraine National Public Health Center (UPHC), through the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Ukraine Office, requested technical assistance from the CDC COVID-19 International Task Force in supporting mitigation efforts for this mass gathering, including specifically for pilgrims traveling from the United States.
The purpose of this report was to describe COVID-19 mitigation measures for the 2021 Rosh Hashanah Pilgrimage to Uman, Ukraine; report the number of COVID-19 cases in NYC and Uman; and assess whether there were any signals of increased COVID-19 transmission in NYC linked to the Uman pilgrimage. The activities of the study, and the partnerships involved herein, exemplify the Supplement theme of Leveraging and Adapting Global Health Systems and Programs During the COVID-19 Pandemic.
This activity was reviewed by CDC and determined to be nonresearch. It was conducted consistent with applicable federal law and CDC policy (see, e.g., 45 C.F.R. part 46, 21 C.F.R. part 56; 42 U.S.C. §241(d); 5 U.S.C. §552a; 44 U.S.C. §3501 et seq.).
The CDC COVID-19 International Task Force engaged multiple groups, including influential American Hasidic leaders, to develop a comprehensive mitigation and communications strategy for the Uman pilgrimage targeting pilgrims in Ukraine and the United States. The project was coordinated by CDC in partnership with UPHC, the Rabbinical Alliance of America, Amudim, and the NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (NYCDOHMH). CDC has been partnering with UPHC since its inception in 2017. During the COVID-19 pandemic, UPHC received funds from CDC to support faith-community engaged contact tracing and mitigation during the Rosh Hashanah pilgrimage. The Rabbinical Alliance of America and Amudim did not receive governmental funding for this study.
Together, project partners developed a fact sheet based upon WHO and CDC COVID-19 guidelines, addressing the need for COVID-19 vaccinations before travel, and mitigation measures during the pilgrimage and upon return to the United States. The fact sheet was translated into Hebrew, Yiddish, and Ukrainian. Forward and backward translation in all languages was conducted in the United States and Ukraine by certified translators. Cognitive testing of the fact sheet was conducted with religious leaders and other community consultants to ensure cultural appropriateness.
Funded by the NYCDOHMH, the fact sheet was disseminated by full-page inserts in 5 major Orthodox publications (Hamodia, Flatbush Jewish Journal, Yated, Der Yid, and Di Tzeitung/News Report) in NYC for 5 days each during August 5‒September 3, 2021, reaching an estimated daily readership of 321,000 persons. The fact sheet was also sent out by various WhatsApp groups. Furthermore, a weekly YouTube show hosted by Rabbi Dr. Glatt, sponsored by Young Israel of Woodmere, New York and promoted by the Rabbinical Alliance of America and other national rabbinical organizations, regularly featured CDC mitigation guidance and reached over 6,000 viewers weekly. The Rabbinical Alliance of America also shared the fact sheet with its listservs, comprising >950 Orthodox rabbis and 1,500 additional congregational and community leaders.
In Uman, concerted COVID-19 mitigation efforts were made by UPHC (Table 1) and the US-based Orthodox Jewish faith-based organization, Amudim (Table 2). UPHC produced 2 videos aimed at the Hasidic Jewish community conveying recommendations for the safe celebration of Rosh Hashanah that were broadcast at the international airports in Kyiv and Lviv, large international airports used by most pilgrims traveling into Ukraine, and in hotels and refectories in Uman. A central billboard was also used on Pushkina Street, the main thoroughfare for the pilgrimage. “Safe Celebration of the Jewish High Holidays” web content was posted across the UPHC website; on the Visit Ukraine Web site, the principal tourist information portal for travelers to Ukraine and Ukrainians planning travel abroad; and through various social media outlets. Recognizing the need to immediately diagnose cases and isolate persons who had COVID-19, UPHC provided 50,000 CLINITEST Rapid COVID-19 antigen tests (Siemens, https://www.siemens.com) to Uman for use during the pilgrimage.
Because the immediate goal was preventing the spread of COVID-19 during the Uman pilgrimage through multiple interventions in the United States and Ukraine, an evaluation of the interventions was not planned as part of the study. However, efforts were made to assess the effect of the study by comparing different data sources.
During the 2021 Uman pilgrimage, UPHC collaborated with the Uman branch of the Uman district of the Cherkasy Central Committee of the Ministry of Health to provide the number of PCR tests used and rapid antigen tests conducted in Uman, as well as the number of positive test results. UPHC also provided the number of COVID-19 cases among service workers in Uman during the pilgrimage and 2 weeks after the pilgrimage.
US Customs and Border Protection (USCBP) provided data regarding the number of travelers returning to NYC from Ukraine after Rosh Hashanah and other high holy days. CDC subsequently provided traveler data to the NYC Test and Trace Corps program (T2). Travelers were advised on quarantine and offered testing and vaccination resources.
COVID-19 incidence in Ukraine for the epidemiologic week starting September 6, 2021, was 6.3 cases/100,000 persons and increased to 10.4 cases/100,000 persons the next epidemiologic week (10). Pilgrims entering Ukraine were required to show a negative COVID-19 PCR test result for a test that was conducted no more than 72 hours before entering Ukraine. According to information received from the Head of the Situational Center of the Main Department of National Police in the Cherkasy region, 34,069 pilgrims came to Uman in 2021 to celebrate Rosh Hashanah, many of whom were US citizens. (Information was received on September 15, 2021, from the Head of the Situational Center of the Main Department of National Police in the Cherkasy region of Serhiy Kovalenko.) That center was created in Uman for the pilgrimage and included representatives of the State Emergency Service of Ukraine, the National Guard, the National Police, and the Border Guard Service. Information about the number of pilgrims was collected through various sources: the Border Guard Service, the International Charitable Rabbi Nachman Fund, and in the 7 points of entry to Uman (by the National Police). COVID-19 vaccination coverage among pilgrims is not known.
Although more pilgrims than usual were expected, given that international travelers were denied entry to Uman in 2020, official reports registered 34,069 pilgrims, a number similar to previous pilgrimages. Amudim reported less crowding in dining facilities than in previous years even if persons did not maintain 2 meters of physical distancing. For example, instead of having 14 persons at dining tables, table wardens ensured that only 6–8 persons used a table at a time. Temporary synagogues and areas of study were set up in Uman to decongest established synagogues that restricted prayers at 50% normal capacity.
During September 6–10, 2021, laboratories in Uman performed 13,267 PCR tests for symptomatic and asymptomatic persons and found 93 positive specimens (0.7% positivity), all among pilgrims. Rapid antigen tests (n = 3,467) were also performed, and none showed positive results. According to the Uman District Department of the Cherkasy Central Committee of the Ministry of Health, 11 additional positive COVID-19 PCR results were identified among pilgrims during predeparture screening at Kyiv Boryspil International Airport. As of September 21, 2021, no COVID-19 cases were registered among Rosh Hashanah service workers or the population in the pilgrimage zone for whom testing was readily available. The Situational Center of the Main Department of National Police in Cherkasy reported that as of September 22, 2021, there were 3,315 pilgrims remaining in the city of Uman. However, no additional testing data were provided during September 6–10, 2021.
The US government imposed COVID-19 mitigation measures for international travelers arriving in the United States, including mask mandates on all US airlines. All air passengers, including US citizens and fully vaccinated persons, were required to have a negative COVID-19 test result within 3 days before date of travel or documentation of COVID-19 recovery in the previous 3 months. A total of 9,936 international air passengers arrived in the United States from Ukraine the week after the pilgrimage, September 8–15, 2021. Most of those passengers were indirect arrivals with connections through airports in Europe. Slightly more than half (n = 5,219, 52.5%) of the total international air passengers from Ukraine arrived at John F. Kennedy (n = 3,661, 36.8%) and Newark (n = 1,558, 15.7%) airports as US First Ports of Entry (12). (Note that cited CBP data are US government–controlled information and, because of legal restrictions, may not be shared beyond provision of this manuscript without explicit written permission; written requests for information may be submitted to
In addition to the proactive call made to travelers, T2 performed case investigations on NYC residents who had positive laboratory-based or point-of-care SARS-CoV-2 test results, at which point contacts were elicited and details about recent travel were captured. During September 8‒October 8, 2021, T2 identified 15 persons who had COVID-19 and reported recent travel to Ukraine. These case-patients provided 22 contacts. T2 investigators observed lower than normal completion rates on case investigations and reluctance to respond to the question “have you traveled?” Although there was increased incidence of COVID-19 in 2 Hasidic neighborhoods in Brooklyn (Borough Park and Williamsburg) during September 2021, T2 determined the increase in Borough Park was unrelated to the pilgrimage because it began before the return of pilgrims; the cause for the increase in Williamsburg is unclear. We compiled COVID-19 incidence rates for these 2 communities (Table 3) (13).
The COVID-19 mitigation efforts for the Uman pilgrimage were a unique collaboration between the CDC COVID-19 International Task Force; Ukraine’s Public Health Center; the CDC Ukraine Office; the CDC COVID-19 State, Tribal, Local, and Territorial Task Force; Orthodox and Hasidic leaders in the United States; and the NYCDOHMH. These efforts highlight the opportunities to mitigate COVID-19 transmission associated with mass gathering events by focusing on mitigation before, during, and after an event. These efforts also highlight the critical need for early planning to coordinate the efforts and interests of diverse participants as it relates to mass gatherings.
Collaborations take time to develop, and cross-border collaborations can take even longer. We also learned that modified data systems might be needed to measure the effect of mitigation efforts during a mass gathering.
Ensuring that culturally appropriate and relevant communications materials were developed and disseminated by trusted entities was the cornerstone to programmatic success. Identifying and developing relationships with key Hasidic leaders in Uman and the United States was critical to mitigation efforts for the Uman pilgrimage. Planning started in February 2021 and required coordination across countries and jurisdictions. Creating culturally appropriate resources for diverse communities required extensive community consultation and piloting. Limited internet uptake among the target population required the of nontraditional communication channels, such as the use of WhatsApp groups, and printing communication materials for distribution. Partnerships enabled multiple communication touchpoints, including Orthodox Jewish print publications and hotlines, videos shown in airports and on major airlines, fact sheets, and COVID-19 hygiene kits and billboards. Mitigation measures focused on vaccination before travel, social distancing and mask wearing during the pilgrimage, and symptom monitoring, as wells as COVID-19 testing and contact tracing.
Future mass gatherings might consider supplementing routine data collection tools with tools specific to the mass gathering to better enable disaggregating test results between host community members and mass gathering participants. A registration system could also assist with active follow-up of mass gathering participants upon their departure and help identify COVID-19 cases associated with the mass gathering.
The positive outcomes of the mitigation efforts for the 2021 Uman pilgrimage were strengthening the partnership between CDC and the UPHC, the collaboration between CDC and the NYCDOHMH, and developing relationships and collaboration with Orthodox and Hasidic leaders in the greater NYC metropolitan area. This program underscored opportunities for future research for enhancing and targeting COVID-19 surveillance efforts to help identify where to focus mitigation efforts for future mass gatherings during pandemics.
Ms. Erickson-Mamane is a supervisory epidemiologist in the Center for Global Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA. Her primary research interests are infectious diseases and translating research into public health practice.
We thank members of the Rabbinical Alliance of America and Amudim Community Resources for their support in development and dissemination of culturally appropriate COVID-19 mitigation materials for the Uman pilgrimage; Melanie Jankum for providing the graphics contained within the various Uman pilgrimage communication prototypes; Chris Keeley, Lisa Hendricks, and Sarah Klem for their partnership in performing outreach to travelers with recent travel to Ukraine and data from case investigations; Eleni Murphy and Crystal Robinson for coordination of and placement of advertisements; the Public Health Center of the Ministry of Health of Ukraine and the New York City Test and Trace team for data collection and storage; and Stephanie Morrison for providing data regarding US travelers.
- World Health Organization. Timeline: WHO's COVID-19 response, 2021 [cited 2022 Jun 21]. https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019/interactive-timeline
- World Health Organization. Key planning recommendations for mass gatherings in the context of COVID-1, 2020 [cited 2022 Jun 21]. WHO-2019-nCoV-POE-mass-gathering-2021.1-eng.pdf
- World Health Organization. Public health for mass gatherings: key considerations, 2015 [cited 2022 Jun 21]. https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/162109
- Bellafante G. When COVID flared again in Orthodox Jewish New York. The New York Times, 2020 [cited 2022 Jun 21]. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/05/nyregion/orthodox-jewish-nyc-coronavirus.html
- COVID-19 spikes in Orthodox Jewish NYC neighborhoods prompts mask crackdown. Huff Post. 2020 Sep 9 [cited 2022 Jun 21]. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/orthodox-jewish-coronavirus-nyc_n_5f73c695c5b6d698bb24f295
- The American Satellite. Why do some Jews visit Uman for Rosh Hashanah? 2020 Sep 3 [cited 2022 Jun 21]. https://www.americanisraelite.com/news/local_news/article_bdc31756-ec6f-11ea-9fa0-b7e271170a7a.html
- McDonald R, Ruppert PS, Souto M, Johns DE, McKay K, Bessette N, et al. Notes from the field: measles outbreaks from imported cases in Orthodox Jewish communities—New York and New Jersey, 2018–2019. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2019;68:444–5.
- Oster M. Israel’s measles outbreak began in Uman, Ukraine. Jewish Telegraphic Agency. 2019 Apr 3 [cited 2022 Jun 21]. https://www.jta.org/quick-reads/israels-measles-outbreak-began-in-uman-ukraine
- Myroniuk A. First coronavirus case identified in Ukraine. Kyiv Post. 2020 Mar 3 [cited 2022 Jun 21]. https://www.kyivpost.com/ukraine-politics/developing-first-coronavirus-case-identified-in-ukraine.html
- World Health Organization Europe. Ukraine, 2021 [cited 2022 Jun 21]. https://www.euro.who.int/en/countries/ukraine
- Ukraine says it will ‘restrict’ pilgrimage to Uman for Rosh Hashanah. Hamodia. 2020 Aug 25 [cited 2022 Jun 21]. https://hamodia.com/2020/08/25/ukraine-says-will-restrict-pilgrimage-uman-rosh-hashanah
- US Customs and Border Protection. Enterprise and reporting data systems, 2021 [cited 2022 Jun 21]. https://www.cbp.gov/trade/automated?language_content_entity=en
- Health New York City. COVID-19 data [cited 2022 Jun 21]. https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-data-neighborhoods.page
TablesCite This Article
Original Publication Date: July 12, 2022
1Current affiliation: Columbia University, New York, New York, USA.