Volume 21, Number 12—December 2015
Pyrethroid and DDT Resistance and Organophosphate Susceptibility among Anopheles spp. Mosquitoes, Western Kenya
We conducted standard insecticide susceptibility testing across western Kenya and found that the Anopheles gambiae mosquito has acquired high resistance to pyrethroids and DDT, patchy resistance to carbamates, but no resistance to organophosphates. Use of non–pyrethroid-based vector control tools may be preferable for malaria prevention in this region.
During the past decade, a massive scale-up of insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) and indoor residual spraying (IRS) of insecticides in malaria-endemic areas worldwide have led to a substantial reduction in mosquitoes and, paired with the use of artemisinin combination treatments, in overall malaria prevalence and incidence (1). However, although most studied sites showed sustained low-level transmission, other sites had stable or resurging malaria cases and vector populations (2–5). It is generally believed that the recent resurgence in malaria was caused in part by increased vector resistance to pyrethroid insecticides related to the intensive use of ITNs and IRS (6–8). Insecticide resistance is among the most critical challenges in malaria control. Although several new insecticides have been tested as alternatives to pyrethroids for IRS, there is strong debate among decision makers at the national level on whether to implement IRS and which insecticides should be used. Comprehensive evaluation of insecticide resistance across different malaria-endemic areas will provide critically needed data on use of new IRS strategies as alternative malaria control tools for further reducing malaria incidence in Africa.
During April 2012–July 2013, we conducted this study in 7 sentinel sites across different malaria-endemic zones in western Kenya (Figure 1). Malaria vector dynamics and parasite prevalence have been studied in 3 sites (9), and ITN coverage was generally >80% (10). Bungoma, Emutete, Iguhu, and Emakakha are in the highland-fringe malaria epidemic area; Chulaimbo, Ahero, and Kisian are in the malaria-endemic basin region of Lake Victoria (lowland). All sample sites were in rural or suburban areas.
Agricultural and public health use of insecticides in each study site was surveyed by using questionnaire surveys in 30 randomly selected households per site. Mosquito larvae were collected from each study site, fed with TetraMin fish food (Spectrum Brands, Inc., Blacksburg, VA, USA), and raised to adults in the insectary at the Kenya Medical Research Institute in Kisumu. The insectary was not regulated for temperature and humidity; ambient temperature (average ≈24°C) and humidity (≈75% relative humidity) were used for the study. Emerged adults were fed with 10% sucrose solution, and 2- to 5-day-old females were used to determine insecticide susceptibility by using the standard World Health Organization (WHO) insecticide susceptibility tube test http://www.who.int/malaria/publications/atoz/9789241505154/en/. Four classes of insecticides were tested, including pyrethroids lambdacyhalothrin (diagnostic dose 0.05%), deltamethrin (4%), and permethrin (0.75%); organochlorine DDT (0.05%); organophosphate malathion (5%); and carbamate bendiocarb (0.1%) (11). The WHO-designated, pyrethroid-susceptible An. gambiae mosquito in Kisumu was used as a control.
Mosquitoes were exposed to each insecticide for 1 h and then maintained in holding tubes with 10% sucrose solution for 24 h. Mortality rates were scored after the 24-h recovery period; the susceptibility status of the mosquito populations was graded according to WHO criteria (11). Knockdown time (time required to render an adult mosquito unable to fly) was recorded every 10 minutes. Tests were done at 26°C ± 2°C and 80% ± 10% relative humidity during the 1-h exposure period and the subsequent 24-h period during which the mosquito would die or recover, with a 12D:12N photoperiod. We tested 200 mosquitoes per site per insecticide; that is, 8 replicates of exposure and 2 replicates of control, with 20 mosquitoes per replicate. A total of 8,400 (200 per site × 7 sites × 6 insecticides) female mosquitoes were tested. Knockdown rates are provided in the Technical Appendix.
We identified species of a subset of randomly selected susceptible and resistant mosquitoes from the bioassay by using 16s rDNA PCR (12). A total of 1,002 specimens were molecularly identified. The real-time TaqMan assay was used to detect knockdown resistance (kdr) gene mutations and genotypes at amino acid position L1014 of the voltage-gated sodium channel gene (12). A total of 579 mosquitoes were examined for kdr mutation.
Results of WHO susceptibility bioassays showed a 100% mortality rate in the susceptible Kisumu An. gambiae reference strain after exposure to all insecticides tested and 50.4%–87.2% in the 7-field An. gambiae sensu lato populations resulting from exposure to all pyrethroids and DDT. These field populations were highly resistant to pyrethroids, demonstrated by an observed mortality rate that was considerably less than the WHO 90% threshold for resistance. The Bungoma population was the most resistant, exhibiting only a 50% mortality rate against permethrin. The WHO susceptibility bioassay also indicated that An. gambiae sensu lato was highly resistant to DDT: mortality rates ranged 50.4%–73.2% at all sites (Figure 2). Five of the 7 study populations were susceptible to bendiocarb, but 2 populations (Iguhu and Bungoma) were resistant (Figure 2). A 100% mortality rate was observed in mosquito populations exposed to malathion at all sites (Figure 2).
PCR analysis found that An. gambiae sensu stricto (s.s.) was the predominant species in Chulaimbo (72.0%), Iguhu (88.0%), Bungoma (90.0%), Emakakha (93.4%), and Emutete (94.0%), whereas An. arabiensis was predominant in Kisian (64.4%) and Ahero (89.3%) (Table 1). The L1014F mutation was not detected in An. gambiae s.s or An. arabiensis mosquitoes at any sites. Frequency of L1014S point mutation was high for An. gambiae s.s. (85.8%–92.9%) except in the Kisian population (33.0%) (Table 2). For An. arabiensis, L1014S mutation frequency was lower (1.2%–39.1%). Homozygosity of L1014S genotype was high in An. gambiae s.s (30.0%–89.3%), but low in An. arabiensis (0–39.1%) (Table 2).
We found through a survey that pyrethroids were the most frequently used insecticide for mosquito control (Technical Appendix Table). Pyrethroids were also frequently used for control of livestock disease vectors and agricultural pests. Most (73.3%–96.6%) surveyed households used pyrethroids for malaria vector control in the form of ITNs and IRS (Technical Appendix Table). Carbamate was mainly used for livestock disease vector control, and organophosphate was used seasonally for crop pest control among a small proportion of households.
This study found high resistance to pyrethroid insecticide in all 7 study populations, no resistance to organophosphate, and patchy distribution of resistance to carbamate insecticide in An. gambiae and An. arabiensis mosquitoes in western Kenya. This finding has critical implications in guiding malaria vector control in Kenya. In Kenya, current policy on IRS use of insecticides is limited to pyrethroids and DDT (13). Considering widespread pyrethroid resistance, non–pyrethroid-based vector control tools may be preferable. There is a growing debate among government decision makers on whether to use organophosphates (such as malathion or chlorpyrifos methyl) and carbamates (such as bendiocarb) for IRS in Kenya. Our finding on the complete susceptibility to organophosphates in malaria vectors suggests that organophosphates are a potentially effective insecticide for IRS. The patchy distribution of resistance to carbamates calls for careful resistance baseline monitoring if carbamates are considered for IRS.
Although we detected widespread and strong phenotypic resistance to pyrethroids in An. gambiae mosquitoes, whether this resistance could result in operational ITN or IRS malaria control failure in the field is unknown. A report from Côte d’Ivoire showed that ITNs remained effective in reducing entomological inoculation rate in an area of higher kdr frequency in An. gambiae mosquitoes (14). Similarly, a cohort study in Malawi found that the use of ITNs reduced the incidence of cases of malaria by 30% in children in an area that has documented moderate levels of pyrethroid resistance and considerable malaria transmission (15). Cost-effectiveness is another consideration. A thorough assessment of the effect of resistance to pyrethroids on the efficacy and cost-effectiveness of LLINs and IRS for malarial disease and transmission will clarify the need to consider a shift from pyrethroids to alternative carbamate or organophosphate insecticides or to other integrated strategies to control malaria.
Ms. Wanjala is a PhD candidate at Kenyatta University and a trainee supported by a research training grant from the National Institutes of Health. Her research interests include vector ecology and malaria epidemiology.
We thank the staff of the Climate and Human Health Research Unit, Centre for Global Health Research, Kenya Medical Research Institute, Kenya, for field assistance. We thank 2 anonymous reviewers for comments and suggestions that greatly improved the manuscript.
This paper was published with permission from the director of Kenya Medical Research Institute. This study was supported by grants from the National Institutes of Health (R01 A1050243 and D43 TW001505).
- World Health Organization. World Malaria Report 2013. Geneva: WHO; 2013 [cited 2015 Aug 8]. http://www.who.int/malaria/publications/world_malaria_report_2013/en/
- Noor AM, Kinyoki DK, Mundia CW, Kabaria CW, Mutua JW, Alegana VA, The changing risk of Plasmodium falciparum malaria infection in Africa 2000–10: a spatial and temporal analysis of transmission intensity. Lancet. 2014;383:1739–47.
- Bayoh MN, Walker ED, Kosgei J, Ombok M, Olang GB, Githeko AK, Persistently high estimates of late night, indoor exposure to malaria vectors despite high coverage of insecticide treated nets. Parasit Vectors. 2014;7:380.
- Ngufor C, Chouaïbou M, Tchicaya E, Loukou B, Kesse N, N'Guessan R, Combining organophosphate-treated wall linings and long-lasting insecticidal nets fails to provide additional control over long-lasting insecticidal nets alone against multiple insecticide-resistant Anopheles gambiae in Côte d’Ivoire: an experimental hut trial. Malar J. 2014;13:396.
- Killeen GF. Characterizing, controlling and eliminating residual malaria transmission. Malar J. 2014;13:330.
- Silva AP, Santos JM, Martins AJ. Mutations in the voltage-gated sodium channel gene of anophelines and their association with resistance to pyrethroids—a review. Parasit Vectors. 2014;7:450.
- World Health Organization Global Malaria Programme. Global plan for insecticide resistance management in malaria vectors. Geneva: The Organization; 2012.
- World Health Organization. Global strategic framework for integrated vector management. Geneva: The Organization; 2014.
- Wanjala CL, Waitumbi J, Zhou G, Githeko AK. Identification of malaria transmission and epidemic hotspots in the Western Kenya highlands: its application to malaria epidemic prediction. Parasit Vectors. 2011;4:81.
- Zhou G, Li JS, Ototo EN, Atieli HE, Githeko AK, Yan G. Evaluation of universal coverage of insecticide-treated nets in western Kenya: field surveys. Malar J. 2014;13:351.
- World Health Organization. Test procedures for insecticide resistance monitoring in malaria ector mosquitoes. Geneva: The Organization; 2013.
- Bass C, Nikou D, Donnelly MJ, Williamson MS, Ranson H, Ball A, Detection of knockdown resistance (kdr) mutations in Anopheles gambiae: a comparison of two new high-throughput assays with existing methods. Malar J. 2007;6:111.
- Mutero CM, Kramer RA, Paul C, Lesser A, Miranda ML, Mboera LEG, Factors influencing malaria control policy-making in Kenya, Uganda and Tanzania. Malar J. 2014;13:305.
- Ouattara AF, Dagnogo M, Constant EA, Kone M, Raso G, Tanner M, Transmission of malaria in relation to distribution and coverage of long-lasting insecticidal nets in central Côte d’Ivoire. Malar J. 2014;13:109.
- Lindblade KA, Mwandama D, Mzilahowa T, Steinhardt L, Gimnig J, Shah M, A cohort study of the effectiveness of insecticide-treated bed nets to prevent malaria in an area of moderate pyrethroid resistance, Malawi. Malar J. 2015;14:31.